The misguided stampede to build gas power plants
This report analyses the financial risks of expanding gas-fired power generation. It highlights tripled capital costs, fuel price volatility, and potential stranded assets. Conversely, renewables and battery storage are presented as more cost-effective, reliable alternatives, with specific case studies from California and Texas demonstrating their growing role in grid stability.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Key findings
Consumers face significant risks from spikes in natural gas prices caused by weather and geopolitical events, which rise in relation to the amount of new gas-fired capacity added to the grid. Rising liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports lead to additional price volatility in the U.S. and persistent long-term cost increases. The price of new combined-cycle gas plants has roughly tripled compared to projects built in the early 2020s, with orders unlikely to be fulfilled until 2030 or later. Conversely, the costs of wind and solar paired with dispatchable battery storage are not tracking the rapid climb of gas prices, hardware is readily available, and they have no fuel costs.
Executive summary
One recent U.S. estimate showed that 133,000 megawatts (MW) of new gas-fired capacity is currently on the drawing board. However, these planned projects overlook major financial risks for utility customers and investors. Utilities generally pass fuel costs directly through to consumers, eliminating corporate financial risk from price spikes. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 and weather-driven spikes demonstrate how these costs are pushed onto consumers. The cost for new gas-fired generation has jumped to at least $2,500 per kilowatt (kW) installed, or $2.5 billion for a 1,000-MW unit. This roughly triples the cost of early 2020s projects and excludes financing or pipeline expansion costs.
The cost of higher gas prices
While gas prices were relatively low for 15 years, historical data shows long stretches of high prices, sometimes reaching $15-$20/MMBtu. The U.S. may be entering a new higher-price period driven by LNG exports and increased domestic consumption for electricity. The Energy Information Administration (EIA) projects Henry Hub prices will average $4.30/MMBtu in 2026 and $4.40/MMBtu in 2027. Wood Mackenzie expects prices to average $4.90/MMBtu from 2030-35. Success in U.S. LNG supply growth effectively comes at a cost to domestic consumers.
The costly problem of price spikes
The impact of rising prices is evident at Dominion Energy’s Greensville facility. In 2021, the plant spent $307.9 million on gas to generate 11.5 million MWh. In 2022, despite producing slightly less electricity, fuel costs soared to $518.7 million. To manage this, state regulators approved a plan to securitise unrecovered fuel costs, resulting in $1.28 billion in securitised debt to be recovered over seven years. Consequently, customers will be paying for 2022’s price spike until May 2031, even as they face new shocks from 2026 winter storms.
Creeping price increases
General price increases also pose risks. IEEFA estimates annual fuel costs at the Greensville plant could jump 41% from its five-year average if Henry Hub prices hit $4.40/MMBtu. Renewables offer better security; Dominion’s 2,600 MW Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind project is estimated to save customers $300 million annually in fuel costs. Similarly, Florida Power & Light reported that its solar buildout saved consumers more than $1.1 billion in fuel costs between 2017 and 2024, with each megawatt-hour of solar generation saving $49.14.
Rising costs undercut gas’ competitiveness
The economic competitiveness of gas-fired generation rested on low capital costs, low fuel costs, and low pipeline costs. All three assumptions are now crumbling. Lazard’s 2025 report notes that capital costs have effectively doubled to an estimated $2,500/kW over the past two years. Power prices from new combined-cycle gas plants are estimated at $107/MWh, while unsubsidised costs for new solar and onshore wind range from $29-$42/MWh and $26-$54/MWh respectively.
Capital costs
Upper bounds for combined-cycle gas turbine capital costs ranged from $1,300 to $1,600 per kW between 2015 and 2025. With current costs reaching $2,500/kW, gas plants are no longer a low-cost electricity source. These elevated levels make it difficult for gas to compete with renewables, even when the latter are firmed with storage.
Fuel costs
Projections for gas power costs often rely on fuel estimates of $3.45/MMBtu, but recent five-year averages and future projections of $4.40 to $4.90/MMBtu indicate higher future costs. For the Greensville plant, a $4.40/MMBtu price would increase annual fuel costs by $122 million compared to its long-term average, costs which would be passed directly to ratepayers.
Pipeline costs
Pipeline construction costs have risen significantly, with a 2025 analysis showing a 90% jump in price per mile for projects completed since 2024. The Mountain Valley Pipeline entered service in 2024 years late and $6.2 billion over its original estimate. For proposed projects like the Bridge Project in South Carolina, reservation fees alone could total $1.18 billion over 20 years, adding 12.3% to the project’s estimated cost.
Competition is intensifying
Developers are currently focused on meeting electricity demand from data centre growth. However, this focus ignores future financial risks. If investment assumptions are flawed, new gas plants risk becoming “stranded assets” that are unable to generate sufficient returns before the end of their 30-year lifetimes, leading to losses that may be recovered from ratepayers.
Gas investments stranded cost risk
Stranded-cost risks are high due to uncertainty in data centre demand and decarbonisation legislation in states like Maryland, Virginia, and North Carolina. AEP Ohio implemented a new tariff requiring large-load customers to contractually commit to pay for 85% of their requested capacity for up to 12 years to separate real proposals from aspirational ones. This reduced requested load studies from over 30,000 MW to just over 13,000 MW.
The rise of battery storage
Battery storage is becoming a clear cost winner, soaking up low-cost renewable power and displacing higher-cost gas. Lazard estimates firmed onshore wind and solar at $44/MWh and $50/MWh. In California, battery storage met 20% of total CAISO demand on February 2, 2026, and alone provided 26.2% of the evening peak at 6 p.m. In Texas, ERCOT’s battery facilities ramped up by 5,000 MW in 50 minutes during peak periods, reducing real-time prices significantly.
Renewables—available now, faster to build, easier to scale
Renewables and storage can meet rising demand more effectively than gas through 2030. In the ERCOT system, expected capacity additions by 2028 include 55,050 MW of “green” capacity (wind, solar, and battery storage) compared to just 3,860 MW of gas. Between 2016 and 2025, wind and solar accounted for 94.5% of ERCOT’s electricity demand growth.
Conclusion
Building new gas plants entails significant financial risks. Sharply higher infrastructure costs, fuel price volatility, and the availability of cheaper, quicker-to-market renewable alternatives make high-cost, long-lived gas investments particularly risky. Solar, wind, and dispatchable battery storage are better for consumers, providing protection against rising costs and shielding them from the high price of new gas-fired capacity.