How do we know where there is potential to intervene and leverage impact in a changing system? The practitioners perspective
This research explores how practitioners identify leverage points for systemic sustainability transformations. It proposes a framework of four nested levels—structures, relationships, goals, and paradigms—drawn from living systems theories. Using case studies like Cotton 2040 and Oneless, it advocates for deeper interventions to achieve transformational, non-linear impact.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Interest in systems change practice has grown as change-makers address increasingly complex sustainability challenges. Practitioners are turning to systems theories and the concept of leverage points to understand how to differentiate between interventions and their relative effects. While traditional mechanical metaphors suggest linear change, this paper proposes revisiting leverage through a living systems perspective to better understand its implications for practice.
Glossary
The research defines key terms used in the framework. Living systems theories incorporate complexity, viewing social systems as part of an evolving ecology. Leverage refers to areas where a small amount of energy has a greater effect, while potential is the process of putting energy into systems to allow future emergence. Transformational systemic change is defined as catalysing change for complex challenges with ambitious goals through systemic cultivation.
Revisiting the concept of leverage with living systems qualities
Management systems often oversimplify dynamic world challenges by designing linear, causal theories of change. This research suggests four qualities of living systems to help practitioners understand change. Firstly, humans and social systems are nested or multi-fractal, meaning actions at a smaller level can influence larger scales. Secondly, the world is relating dynamically, requiring a focus on flows and exchanges rather than static entities. Thirdly, systems change through emergence and self-organisation, necessitating experimentation and learning. Finally, human consciousness allows for self-reflection and choice, enabling a shift in societal systems towards regenerative outcomes.
Nested patterns of systems: levels of potential
The paper introduces four archetypes of how systems change to help identify where to leverage or cultivate impact. These levels build on Donella Meadows’ seminal work on leverage points but are depicted as nested within each other. This structure suggests that intervening at the level of paradigm affects all other levels. Practitioners are urged to look for where energy for change is building or where multiple forces are converging.
The four levels of potential for changing systems
A summary framework is provided to understand where to look for potential, how it relates to strategy, and which indicators to watch. The four levels consist of structures and flows, relationships and organisation, whole system goals, and paradigms.
Reconfiguring structures and flows
This level involves the physical structures, feedback loops, and value chains that are most visible in a system. Shifting these is difficult as it often requires rebuilding the entire system. Case studies like the Protein Challenge and the Oneless project in London demonstrate how mapping value chains or infrastructure can reveal opportunities to reconfigure flows. Potential is often found where there is building momentum, a lack of diverse relationships, or broken information flows.
Re-patterning of relationships, cultivating systemic ways of organising
Surrounding visible structures is the ability of a system to organise through social arrangements, rules, and power dynamics. The research notes that power is a critical energy between relationships. Potential for change is found in the emergence of new models like Holacracy or Sociocracy, and in initiatives like Civil Society Futures, which created a PACT (Power, Accountability, Connection, Trust) to shift how organisations operate. The Lankelly Chase Foundation also applies these principles by ensuring decision-making is devolved and accountability is mutual.
Alignment and coordination towards whole system goals
Human intentions often drive systems towards unsustainable goals, such as continual growth. Reframing these goals is a powerful intervention. For example, Forum for the Future reframed the meat production challenge as ‘fulfilling the global protein needs of nine billion people’, while the Oneless project reframed its goal as the ‘hydration of Londoners without single-use plastics’. Such reframing enables coordinated action across networks and coalitions.
Shifting paradigms
The deepest potential for leverage exists at the level of paradigms—the worldviews and beliefs that source our systems. Shifting paradigms involves questioning unstated assumptions and narratives. The Marine CoLAB seeks to shift the narrative of the ocean from economic value to intrinsic well-being. Boundless Roots uses inquiry to explore the collective paradigms that inhibit transformation regarding the climate crisis. This level requires cultivating the ability of people to navigate multiple ways of seeing and being in the world.
Reflections and implications for our understanding of impact
Choosing where to intervene is not an exact science but requires systemic awareness. Practitioners should focus on ‘deeper’ leverage points, such as new ways of organising and shifting paradigms, which have more transformative potential despite being harder to measure. Impact should be viewed as working with change rather than attempting to hold it static for measurement. Redefining impact involves being able to work with a dynamically changing world, requiring a shift in mind-set for decision-makers and funders.