Ethics & technology: Ethical considerations relating to the provision of insights obtained through the use of technology to an audited entity
This guidance explores the ethical implications for auditors sharing technology-derived insights with audited entities. It details how to distinguish between audit and non-audit services, identifies potential threats to independence—such as management and self-review threats—and provides illustrative examples for applying these principles to artificial intelligence and data analytics.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
During an audit, auditors may obtain a variety of insights about an entity or its environment through the use of technology. The prevalence of artificial intelligence (AI) in auditing is expected to increase the quantity of these insights by facilitating new forms of procedure and acting as a catalyst for traditional data analytics. Reporting these insights to management or those charged with governance can create threats to integrity, objectivity, or independence, particularly when the work performed to obtain the insight is not part of the statutory audit of financial statements. This guidance aims to reduce the risk of compromised ethical standards and provide auditors with confidence in applying requirements to support the public interest through enhanced internal controls and corporate reporting.
Is communication of the insight required by the auditing standards?
International Standards on Auditing (UK) require the communication of certain information, including significant findings and deficiencies in internal control (ISAs 260 and 265). For instance, an auditor using data analytics for a bad debt provision may identify that certain customer groups take progressively longer to pay, which has implications for management’s provisioning assumptions. Similarly, a machine learning algorithm might identify a significant control deficiency where total project expenditure bypasses higher-level approval policies. Required communications also extend to identified fraud, non-compliance with laws, and matters casting significant doubt on going concern. Such required communications do not constitute non-audit services and do not pose threats to integrity or independence.
Would communication of the insight constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour?
Determining whether an insight constitutes a non-audit service or a favour is a matter of professional judgement. A communication is part of the audit if its objective is to gather evidence to support the audit opinion, the firm determines the nature and extent of testing, and the terms match the audit engagement. If a communication is not part of the audit but is provided under a formal or tacit agreement, it constitutes a non-audit service. The FRC Ethical Standard discusses favours, noting that insights not part of the audit may be perceived as favours if market fees are not charged. Such favours are only permitted if an Objective, Reasonable and Informed Third Party (ORITP) would consider their value trivial or inconsequential based on the cost to the audit firm.
Would communication of the insight pose a threat to integrity, objectivity or independence?
Four primary threats are identified as relevant. A management threat arises if the auditor plays a role in decision-making. Factors heightening this include management lacking expertise to critically evaluate the insight, the opacity of the technology, or a high frequency of communications causing management to rely on the auditor as part of their control environment. A self-review threat occurs if the auditor audits information that reflects their own previous work, especially if the generation of the insight involved subjective judgement or proprietary firm technology. Self-interest threats may arise if the communication indicates the firm is seeking future fee-generating work. Finally, a familiarity threat may emerge if the auditor regularly provides insights unrelated to the audit process, suggesting they are too close to management.
Ethical considerations in relation to providing an audited entity with access to technology that enables it to derive insights
Providing an entity with direct access to technology used in the audit involves similar ethical considerations. Provision of access is part of the audit only if it facilitates interactions supporting the fulfilment of auditing standards, such as temporary access to a process mining tool to discuss control deficiencies. It is less likely to be part of the audit if it allows continuous monitoring for the entity’s own purposes. Management threats are evaluated based on the duration of access, the reusability of the technology, and the extent to which the technology itself generates evaluative outputs rather than just providing a platform for management’s own analysis. Self-review threats are also present if management uses auditor-provided technology to arrive at financial figures that the auditor subsequently audits.
Illustrative examples
The guidance provides two examples. In the first, a firm provides customer insights derived from separate work not required for the audit opinion. Because this was discussed during a tender, it was judged a tacit agreement and thus a non-audit service and a favour. However, since the insight was presented in neutral language and management had the expertise to evaluate it, the service was deemed permitted. In the second example, an observation regarding supplier concentration arose directly from audit work performed for an expense audit. As no additional work was performed and the nature of the work was determined by the auditor for the audit opinion, the communication did not constitute a non-audit service or a favour and was permitted without formal threat documentation.