An expanding mandate: A systems-level framework for asset management
This report from the Thinking Ahead Institute and CAIA Association argues for expanding the investment mandate to incorporate systems-level thinking. Drawing on a survey of 176 asset managers and roundtables with 120 senior executives, it presents an inside-out, outside-in framework for navigating polycrisis and long-term systemic risks.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
The report argues that investment management’s prevailing mental models are clashing with an increasingly complex operating environment. Grounded in the Thinking Ahead Global Asset Manager Peer Study 2026 — drawing on 176 asset managers, approximately 25,000 data points, and USD $39 trillion in AUM — alongside nearly 20 hours of structured dialogue with 120 executives across eight financial centres and surveys of CAIA Association’s 15,000 members, this work proposes an inside-out, outside-in (IOOI) framework to help investment organisations tune themselves from the inside out and adapt from the outside in.
Addressing the gap
The investment industry faces a cognitive and structural gap. Practitioners are absorbed in narrow mandates, and institutional machinery rewards precision within silos rather than systemic awareness. Hyper-specialisation, short performance cycles, and benchmark-relative mandates combine to penalise the broader vision that systems thinking requires. The operating environment is in a state of polycrisis, with multiple systemic risks compounding simultaneously. Systems thinking is described as the cognitive skill of the 21st century.
Inside-out: How managers shape the ecosystem
Macro | The future systemic points of pressure
Several macro forces are reshaping the investment landscape simultaneously. Wealth channel AUM in semi-liquid structures grew to roughly USD $500 billion by year-end 2025, tripling from 2022 to 2025 (p.11). Geopolitical risk has become a principal axis by which capital flows are re-organising. When the U.S. raised tariffs on Chinese goods by 145 percentage points in early 2025, U.S. imports from China fell to depths not seen since the 2009 financial crisis (p.12). Carbon Tracker estimates fossil fuel companies risk wasting up to USD $2.2 trillion in the next decade on projects that could prove uneconomic (p.12). Demographic decline and AI’s systemic implications further compound the need for integrative thinking.
Meso | Broadening purpose and vision
The report profiles asset owners already operating with a systems-level mandate. CalSTRS’s Collaborative Model generated over USD $550 million in savings in 2024 alone, operating at an investment cost of 43.8 basis points against a peer benchmark of 63.1 basis points (p.18). Ownership Works has recruited 34 private equity firms with over USD $1 trillion in AUM to commit to creating USD $20 billion in working-class wealth by 2030 (p.17). Investment organisations are urged to embrace double materiality, internalise externalities, and adopt a 3D investing framework: risk, return, and real-world impact.
Outside-in: How managers may adapt to the evolving ecosystem
Micro I: Organisational effectiveness
Effective organisations must manage multiple goals beyond benchmark performance. The report identifies four investment models: Multiple Goals, Best Ideas, Talent Source, and Private-Public. Data from the Thinking Ahead Global Asset Manager Peer Study indicates an Org-Alpha deficit — managers have elements of organisational alpha in place but not in a fully integrated form (p.24–25).
Micro II: Organisational preparedness
Preparedness is assessed across four Next Gen dimensions: Business, Investing, Professional, and Vision. Managers score strongly on investment expertise but weakly on sense-making, bridge-building, systems navigation, and tech-connecting. Four weaknesses are highlighted: organisational efficiency, an effective human capital model, adaptiveness and resilience, and licence to operate (p.28–29).
Conclusion | The system and the future are no longer ahead of us
The system and the future are no longer ahead of us. System-level investing is identified as one of the most important areas of work facing the industry today.
Call to action: How asset management can adapt
Asset managers are urged to widen the mandate, rewrite success metrics, rebuild for systems thinking, and integrate macro forces into underwriting, portfolio construction, stewardship, and mandates. Organisations should redesign hiring, talent development, and career paths to prioritise synthesis and integrative capability alongside deep expertise.