Impact portfolio construction yesterday, today, and tomorrow
This research document examines methodologies for incorporating social and environmental impact into asset class allocation. It reviews current practices, compares strategic and tactical allocation approaches, and addresses challenges such as data limitations and liquidity. The findings are based on a literature review and interviews with over 30 leading investors.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Executive summary
This discussion document reviews the current state of practice in impact-driven portfolio construction and optimisation across various asset classes. It serves as an introduction to a series of case studies highlighting novel practices developed by individual investors. The project’s primary aims are to inspire asset owners and allocators to consider impact during the determination of asset allocation and to provide examples of how leading investors are already doing so. The research is based on a review of 35 academic papers and book chapters, 17 publicly available practitioner publications, and interviews with more than 30 leading investors.
State of practice
Available evidence suggests that multi-asset class capital allocation and impact management disciplines remain largely non-interoperable. The majority of multi-asset class impact investors do not incorporate impact into asset class allocation, typically seeking impact within classes determined by an existing allocation. However, some family offices pursue high-impact opportunities regardless of asset class, allowing the allocation to land where it may. The report provides six anonymised examples of unique approaches. For instance, one organisation uses tactical allocation informed by impact ratings, while another allocates by risk profile (e.g., 20% to frontier funds) rather than traditional asset classes to address constraints preventing capital flow to impact-first funds.
Introduction to asset allocation (optional review)
Asset allocation has evolved from ad-hoc methods to formalised theories like Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT), developed by Harry Markowitz. MPT focuses on maximising financial return while reducing risk through mean-variance analysis. The “efficient frontier” represents portfolios offering the greatest expected return for a given level of risk. Other models include the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) and factor-based models, such as Fama and French’s five-factor framework. The Total Portfolio Approach (TPA) focuses on risk and return streams rather than traditional asset classes, enabling the integration of non-financial criteria and a more holistic approach to portfolio construction.
Getting started: strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation
Investors distinguish between strategic asset allocation (SAA), which identifies long-term target allocations (e.g., 50% equities, 40% debt), and tactical asset allocation (TAA), which is more active and short-term. SAA involves periodic rebalancing to maintain original goals. TAA allows for opportunistic deviations within set ranges established around SAA targets. Both approaches offer potential paths for impact-informed allocation: either by adapting mathematical models to incorporate impact or by establishing systematic ways to deviate from model recommendations to account for impact.
A mountain too high? Incorporating impact into strategic asset allocation
While adapting SAA models to include impact variables is theoretically possible, experts highlight significant obstacles. Limitations include data accuracy issues, as impact data often has high “measurement error,” and the sensitivity of optimisation models to small input variances. Furthermore, impact is not just an input but a goal (or “output”) that investors value for its own sake. Bridgewater Associates offers an applied example, considering ESG impact goals alongside financial risk and return as a three-dimensional “cube” during the screening of the investment universe.
Screening and optimising for impact within a traditional SAA
A structured approach presented by Credit Suisse involves dividing the investment universe into five categories in descending order of impact: Impact Investing (emphasising additionality), Sustainable thematic investing, ESG Integration, Exclusions, and Traditional investments. Within each asset class, investors fill allocations by prioritising impact investments first, followed by sustainable thematic and ESG strategies. Neuberger Berman similarly suggests incorporating climate risk directly into the SAA process to identify climate impact variation across sectors and classes, which might otherwise be unrecognised at a bottom-up level.
A practical alternative: incorporating impact into tactical asset allocation
A simpler path for many investors involves establishing wide ranges around SAA targets and following simple heuristics. Investors can rank-order their pipeline based on expected impact and financial returns. For example, an investor might shift from a 20% public debt allocation to 15% to increase private debt holdings to 25% if the latter offers superior impact. Visual tools, such as integrated impact-financial scatterplots or charts comparing “best” and “worst” opportunities across adjacent asset classes, help investors identify where selling a lower-impact asset to buy a higher-impact one improves overall performance. Methods such as Social Return on Investment (SROI) can estimate monetary values for impact, though they may not capture all dimensions.
Additional considerations: liquidity and duration
Impact portfolio construction must account for the duration of impact and the liquidity of holdings. Tactical reallocation is often constrained by the illiquidity of private market investments. Investors should consider whether impact increases or decays over long holding periods. For instance, if short-term loans yield less impact, the illiquidity of longer-term holdings may be acceptable. Conversely, if the impact of investor contribution (additionality) fades quickly, long capital tie-ups could restrict the ability to reallocate to new, more impactful opportunities.
Next steps: case studies
Systematically incorporating impact into asset class optimisation remains a challenge tackled by only a few leaders. This document serves as an introduction to a series of forthcoming case studies that will highlight new approaches to impact-driven portfolio construction and optimisation. These real-world examples aim to inspire other investors by showcasing the advances made by pioneering practitioners in the field.