A guide to classifying the impact of an investment
This research document provides a guide for asset owners and managers to classify the impact of investment products. It defines 13 impact classes based on the impact of underlying assets and the investor’s contribution. The framework uses five dimensions of impact to assess performance and align portfolios with intentions.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
This guide, and the associated excel template, have been designed to provide asset owners and managers with high-level, step-by-step guidance to classify the impact of individual investment products. The Impact Management Project (IMP) collaborated with over 2,000 investors and enterprises to develop this framework, aiming to provide a standardised method for differentiating the types of impact that investments have, even when varying measurement approaches are used.
Classifying the impact of an investment
A growing number of investors are motivated to manage the effects of their investment portfolios on people and the planet. These investors vary widely in their intentions and constraints, ranging from retail investors looking to mitigate risk by avoiding harmful activities to institutional investors seeking to address social issues in their clients’ communities. To efficiently align portfolios with their intentions, all investors need to understand the impact of the variety of enterprises or investment products available to them.
Intermediary asset managers and enterprises also want to identify aligned investors and avoid being judged solely on financial performance or being compared inappropriately to opportunities with different impact profiles. In response, the IMP developed “impact classes,” which group investments with similar characteristics based on impact performance data or goals. An impact class combines the impact of an investment’s underlying assets with the contribution the investor makes to this impact. This grouping offers a complementary shorthand for conveying whether an investment matches an investor’s impact intentions.
The impact asset classes
The 13 impact asset classes have been designed to help investors describe the impact performance or goals of an investment or portfolio. An investment’s impact is defined as a function of two variables: the impact of the underlying assets or enterprises (the x-axis) and the contribution that the investor makes to enable the enterprise or intermediary manager to achieve that impact (the y-axis).
Impact of underlying assets
The first step in classification is determining the impact of the underlying asset. There are five possible classifications: May Cause Harm; Does Cause Harm; Act to Avoid Harm; Benefit Stakeholders; and Contribute to Solutions. “Act to Avoid Harm” signifies the enterprise prevents or reduces significant negative outcomes. “Benefit Stakeholders” means the enterprise also generates positive outcomes for people and the planet. “Contribute to Solutions” identifies enterprises that generate significant effects on positive outcomes for otherwise underserved populations.
To determine this, investors assess data across five dimensions: What outcome occurs and its importance; Who experiences the outcome and how underserved they are; How Much of the outcome occurs (scale, depth, and duration); the Enterprise Contribution (what would likely happen anyway); and the Risk that impact does not occur as expected. Performance data should be collected against 15 impact data categories within these dimensions to enable a clear assessment.
The guide provides an illustrative case study of a healthcare enterprise assessing its effects. One effect (CO2 emissions mitigation) is classified as “Act to Avoid Harm,” while another (access to healthcare services) is classified as “Benefit Stakeholders.” A third effect (providing decent income to underserved employees) is classified as “Contribute to Solutions” because it involves deep, long-term change for an underserved group. Since the enterprise contributes to a solution for a societal challenge, its overall impact is classified as “Contribute to Solutions.”
Contribution made by the investor
Investors can employ four primary investment strategies to contribute to the impact made by an enterprise. These strategies are not mutually exclusive and are often used in combination. “Signal that impact matters” involves choosing to favour or avoid certain investments to lead to a “pricing-in” of social and environmental effects by capital markets. “Engage actively” involves using expertise and networks to improve business performance, including proactive efforts to improve effects on people and the planet.
“Grow new or undersupplied capital markets” occurs when an investor anchors or participates in new or overlooked opportunities, often taking on additional complexity, illiquidity, or perceived higher risk. Finally, “Provide flexible capital” involves accepting lower risk-adjusted returns to generate specific kinds of impact, such as patient capital for marginalised populations that cannot offer a commercial return.
Classifying an investment
By combining the asset’s impact with the investor’s contribution, an investment can be classified against the 13 impact classes. Portfolios may contain a range of impacts or varying investor strategies. In such cases, products can be split across classes. For example, the illustrative “Health Fund I” is mapped by its performance, showing 10% in one class, 15% in another, and 75% in a third. If a product is new, its goals can be plotted instead. This matrix informs asset owner decisions on whether to reallocate to a specific portfolio or invest elsewhere.
Appendix
The appendix provides a template for assessing impact across the five dimensions using indicators, raw data, analysis, and assessment levels. It also lists illustrative approaches for each investor strategy. For example, an investor might signal that impact matters by requiring a company to share impact data during due diligence, or engage actively by providing specialist sector expertise. Growing new markets might involve making a cornerstone investment in a first-time fund manager or structuring a social impact bond.