Climateworks Centre submission to the National Electricity Market wholesale market settings review draft report consultation
This submission by Climateworks Centre recommends prioritising demand flexibility and distributed energy resources in National Electricity Market reforms. It advocates for aligning infrastructure planning with net zero commitments, developing demand-side out-of-market reserves, and establishing a demand-side statement of opportunities to ensure a cost-effective transition and reduce gas reliance.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Climateworks Centre welcomes the opportunity to provide a submission to the independent panel regarding the National Electricity Market (NEM) wholesale market settings review draft report. The rapid decarbonisation of Australia’s electricity and energy system is considered essential for meeting obligations under the Paris Agreement. Electricity generation remains the nation’s largest source of greenhouse gas emissions, and the adoption of renewables is expected to reduce emissions by approximately one-third while enabling the decarbonisation of other sectors of the economy.
Context: Australia’s zero-emissions electricity and energy system
Climateworks’ 2023 analysis focuses on least-cost pathways to decarbonise the economy in line with a 1.5°C temperature goal. This modelling informs planning tools such as the 2026 Integrated System Plan (ISP). Under this pathway, renewable energy generation makes up 83 per cent of total electricity generation by 2030 and close to 100 per cent by 2034. Clean electricity capacity, comprising generation and storage, is projected to expand from 55 GW today to approximately 151 GW by 2030 and 398 GW by 2050.
The transition involves the cessation of all coal-fired power generation by 2035. Gas-powered generation is expected to reduce by 69 per cent by 2030 and 96 per cent by 2050. Generation capacity from distributed solar PV is forecast to increase from 7.1 GW in 2022 to 114 GW in 2050. Furthermore, electricity storage will be a substantial component, with the system requiring 15 GW of battery storage by 2030 and 55 GW by 2050. Economy-wide gas use is projected to fall by 54 per cent by 2030 and 90 per cent by 2050 relative to 2022 levels. Electrifying the transport sector and producing renewable hydrogen will require significant additional electricity, reaching 228 TWh and 344 TWh respectively by 2050.
Capturing the opportunities presented by demand flexibility, DER and electrification
Integrating demand-side energy management is essential for a cost-effective transition and managing rapid demand growth. Modelling indicates that cumulative energy savings of 9,656 PJ are achievable between 2025 and 2050 across all sectors. The built environment represents the largest opportunity with 4,469 PJ of cumulative savings, followed by industry and waste at 3,720 PJ. Annual savings across all sectors are expected to grow from 249 PJ in 2030 to 594 PJ in 2050.
Designing an electricity and energy system consistent with government policy commitments
Climateworks identifies shortcomings in current Australian Energy Regulator (AER) guidelines, which require AEMO to select an optimal development path based on the ‘most likely’ scenario. This approach may exclude jurisdictional policies that do not meet certain committed thresholds. It is recommended that the ISP process be revised to select the path ‘most consistent with government policy commitments’ to ensure infrastructure is designed to deliver on democratically decided targets rather than lagging behind policy ambitions.
Delivering NEM Review recommendations that will be effective within the future electricity energy system
Wholesale market settings must anticipate and enable future system architecture to avoid barriers to transition and increased costs. Climateworks supports draft recommendations for improving longer-term incentives for generation but highlights a gap regarding additional policy for the orderly closure of thermal generation. Mechanisms such as carbon pricing, emissions intensity standards, or regulated closure dates are suggested to ensure strategic exits from the market.
Recommendation 1: Ensure that proposed market reforms promote a broad range of energy solutions, including industrial demand flexibility and distributed energy resources (DER), to meet all energy objectives while reducing reliance on gas peaking plants
Reforms should prioritise the integration of demand flexibility and DER across the Enhanced System Energy Market (ESEM), derivatives, and spot markets. This approach reduces reliance on gas peaking plants and fossil fuel baseload generation. The submission suggests that standardized contracts for the Managed Market Operator (MMO) should explicitly consider the requirements of different participants, such as small aggregators and industrial demand-response providers.
Recommendation 2: Set out processes and principles for setting ESEM infrastructure investment targets that integrate jurisdictional policies with national net zero objectives for the economy and ensure cohesive and cost-effective planning across all energy market users
Investment targets should bridge jurisdictional energy policies with national planning. Clear eligibility criteria should ensure long-term ESEM contracts are available only to resources consistent with the National Electricity Objective on emissions reductions. This provides certainty for investors and ensures that transition efforts remain affordable and reliable.
Recommendation 3: Accelerate the development of out-of-market reserves, with a focus on demand-side contracts and integrated electricity and gas system planning, to support an orderly transition from fossil fuel baseload generation and avoid overreliance on gas peaking infrastructure
Out-of-market reserves are necessary to manage rare risks such as extended winter conditions. However, Climateworks cautions against overreliance on new gas peakers, which could delay thermal exits and burden consumers. Integrating electricity and gas system planning is recommended to ensure reserves deliver reliability at lower costs and with fewer emissions by utilizing demand response and storage.
Recommendation 4a: Promote efficient market uptake of demand-response, including through development of a demand-side statement of opportunities (DSOO) and comprehensive demand-side strategy, to improve investment efficiency and outcomes for consumers and the economy
The development of a comprehensive demand strategy and a demand-side statement of opportunities (DSOO) is recommended. These tools would map available demand-side resources and outline how market mechanisms can capture their value, aiding in investment decisions and improving coordination across jurisdictions.
Recommendation 4b: Strengthen locational information and regional planning frameworks, including development of regional ISPs for key industrial precincts, to support targeted infrastructure investment
Regional ISPs for key industrial precincts would provide clarity and confidence in regions with high potential industrial electricity demand. This place-based planning approach enables industrial actors to integrate resources and share clean energy alternatives, supported by enhanced reporting obligations for large industrial users.