Investment and governance: Through the lens of sustainability
This research examines how sustainable investment drives firms to adopt sustainability-oriented governance. Using a global sample, it finds a 1% increase in sustainable debt raises the likelihood of adopting sustainable governance by 9.2%, subsequently improving environmental performance by 16%. These effects are primarily observed in non-financial firms.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Achieving global climate objectives requires targeted financial commitments, with one estimate suggesting that an annual investment of approximately $9.4 trillion is needed for decarbonisation efforts to reach net-zero by 2050. The global fixed income market is a pivotal pillar for gathering this capital; in 2022, corporate sustainable debt reached approximately $1.7 trillion. This paper explores whether sustainable investment motivates firms to implement organisational changes, specifically by adopting sustainable governance practices. Drawing on signalling literature, the researchers hypothesise that firms adopt these changes to signal their commitment to the market, especially as sustainable debt issuance necessitates reporting compliance, including impact reports and third-party certifications required under green bond principles.
Data
The study utilizes sustainable fixed income data from the Bloomberg Global Fixed Income and Environmental Finance databases, combined with sustainability governance metrics from BoardEx. Financial fundamentals are sourced from Worldscope and Global Compustat, while environmental scores are obtained from Refinitiv ESG. The final dataset comprises 6,925 firms and 59,019 firm-year observations spanning 2013 to 2022. During this period, 30% of firms (3,053) implemented significant organisational changes for sustainability. The sample includes 3,944 sustainable bonds, of which 3,056 are green bonds, with the remainder being social, sustainability, and sustainability-linked instruments. These firms are primarily from the financial, industrial, healthcare, and materials sectors, located largely in the United States, United Kingdom, France, Germany, Canada, and Australia.
Event study and regression specification
The researchers conducted an event study to examine changes in sustainable debt issuance around the year of sustainable governance adoption. They evaluated both the amount issued (scaled by total debt) and the number of bonds issued from two years before to two years after the event. The study found that the actual trend in sustainable debt issuance is steeper following the adoption of sustainable governance compared to counterfactual scenarios. A linear probability specification was employed to understand how issuance inspires adoption, controlling for industry, year, and country-level fixed effects.
Endogeneity problem and identification design
To address potential simultaneity and reverse causality—where organisational change might trigger debt issuance or vice versa—the study employs identification through heteroskedasticity. This methodology leverages shifts in the variance of variables across different regimes to resolve simultaneous equations. The dataset was divided into three periods (2013-2018, 2019-2020, and 2021-2022) surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, which served as an exogenous shock that altered the dynamics of organisational change. The authors argue this approach provides more reliable causal estimates than traditional quasi-natural experiments, which often suffer from unverifiable exclusion restrictions.
Results and discussion
Structural GMM estimates reveal that a 1% increase in the amount of sustainable debt issuance increases the probability of adopting sustainable governance by 9.2%. This causal effect is significantly larger than the 5.5% estimate obtained through standard OLS regressions, suggesting that studies using traditional metrics may underestimate the real organisational impact by approximately two-thirds. While superior governance does attract increased investment (a 1% increase in governance adoption raises future debt issuance by 4.2%), the impact of investment on governance is notably stronger.
The findings indicate that these effects are more pronounced in financial sector firms (7.5% increase in adoption probability) compared to polluting sectors (3.1%). Furthermore, the relationship is stronger in civil law countries (10.4%) than in common law countries (4.4%), likely because investment serves as a more powerful motivator for improvement in regions where investor protections are traditionally weaker. The study also confirms that sustainable governance enhances a firm’s environmental performance by 16% to 18%, although these benefits are confined to non-financial firms. For financial firms, internal governance changes did not significantly improve the environmental performance of their sustainable loan borrowers.
Conclusion
The research demonstrates that sustainable investment acts as a catalyst for firms to adopt governance structures oriented towards sustainability. This suggests a reversal of the conventional sequence where governance reforms are needed to attract capital. For policymakers, these results imply that mandating sustainable debt instruments may be more effective at inducing organisational reform than mandating governance structures alone. While the core relationship is universal, its magnitude varies by legal environment and operational sector, highlighting the pivotal role of the financial sector in the global transition toward sustainability.