Sustainable fiduciary duties for investors: How fiduciary duties can be a key to escape the climate prisoner’s dilemma
1. Identify report theme. 2. Summarise key findings. 3. Finalise text. 4. Verify length. This report argues that fiduciary duties require investors to address climate systemic risks. Fiduciaries should avoid new unabated high-emission projects and integrate climate externalities into assessments. Collective action can resolve the “prisoner’s dilemma,” protecting portfolios from potential 40% value losses.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
The duties of fiduciaries – a short introduction
Financial fiduciaries, such as pension trustees, bank directors, and asset managers, are subject to duties categorised into three areas. Firstly, they must act in the best interests of beneficiaries, which generally means providing the greatest financial benefits for present and future beneficiaries. Secondly, fiduciaries must act with undivided loyalty, maintaining good faith and avoiding conflicts of interest. Thirdly, they have an objective duty to exercise care as an ordinary prudent person would, guided by verified facts and science rather than personal or political convictions.
Climate risk is intensifying
Climate change is accelerating, with the last two years seeing unprecedented heatwaves on land and in the oceans. The median temperature rise is now expected to be 2.7°C, with a 40% chance of exceeding 3°C—a threshold associated with high systemic risks and climate tipping points. Authoritative reports suggest the world is on course for a catastrophic temperature rise. Research indicates that the risk of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Current (AMOC) collapsing before 2050 is estimated at 59% (± 17%). Such events could lead to abrupt cooling in Europe and significant disruptions to global food and water security.
Climate risk is a material existential risk to our economy, and therefore a direct and material financial risk to investments
System-level climate risks pose a material financial threat. Studies point to potential GDP losses of 30% to 50% within current lifetimes if tipping points occur. In a business-as-usual scenario, assets could lose more than 40% of their net present value. However, these losses could be limited to less than 10% if the Paris Agreement goals are pursued. The opportunity costs of inaction are substantial, while a rapid green energy transition is likely to be beneficial even without accounting for climate benefits. Fast transition savings are estimated to range between $88 trillion and $775 trillion.
Fiduciaries have obligations to take effective action, to mitigate further material financial climate and system-level risks
To meet their duty to act in the best interests of beneficiaries, fiduciaries should follow five pillars of climate action. Pillar one requires fiduciaries to avoid new unabated high-emission projects to reduce physical and system-level risk. Pillar two involves integrating physical, stranded asset, and litigation risks into return on investment (ROI) assessments. Pillar three focuses on transition finance, accounting for portfolio-wide system-level positive externalities. Pillar four mandates active stewardship to encourage investee companies to adopt sustainable business models. Finally, pillar five involves policy advocacy to create a level playing field and internalise sustainability costs.
No good reasons not to take effective action
Arguments for delaying action based on the perceived remoteness of climate damage are no longer valid. The need for lead-time is critical, as inaction commits the world to irreversible risks. The report rejects the notion that individual action is ineffective, noting that fiduciaries can resolve the collective action problem by consistently applying these duties. Legal precedents such as the Urgenda case highlight that entities have a responsibility to do their part in preventing global harm. Furthermore, fiduciaries should consider the impact of their investments on the entire portfolio, as negative externalities from one company can damage the profitability of other assets.
Can fiduciaries go further and pursue purely non-financial climate goals?
While the primary focus is financial, legal precedents like Harries v Church Commissioners suggest that trustees may take non-financial factors into account if beneficiaries share those concerns and there is no risk of significant financial detriment. However, the report stresses that climate action is increasingly an economic necessity. Delays in mitigation increase the risk of stranded assets, with global capital value at risk potentially rising to $557 trillion if a ban on carbon-intensive investment is delayed until 2030.
Conclusion
The application of fiduciary law must evolve as facts change. Inaction is now deemed more costly than robust mitigation. Fiduciaries should embed climate risks into decision-making by performing fund and portfolio-wide risk analyses. They must ensure that managers follow system-level management principles and interrogate disclosures that may understate risks. Transitioning to a low-carbon economy aligned with the Paris Agreement offers economic benefits that vastly outweigh its costs, such as the estimated $78 trillion net benefit from phasing out coal power plants.