From principles to practice: Financing disaster risk reduction and residual risk
This report analyses the integration of financing for disaster risk reduction and residual risk within national policy frameworks. Drawing on case studies from South Africa, Tonga, and Pakistan, it identifies coordination gaps and emphasises the need for quantified risk data and costed strategies to enhance disaster resilience.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
The economic costs of disasters are rising globally, necessitating the efficient deployment of resources across the disaster risk management (DRM) spectrum. For 15 to 20 years, the efficiency of these efforts has been undermined by fragmented approaches where financing for disaster risk reduction (DRR) and residual risk remain siloed. However, intergovernmental organisations like the G20, particularly under South Africa’s 2025 presidency, have begun publishing principles to better integrate these disciplines. Financing for DRR focuses on prevention and resilience, while pre-arranged financing (PAF) addresses residual risk through financial instruments for response, early recovery, and reconstruction.
Introduction
The 4th International Conference on Financing for Development (FfD4) in 2025 underscored that disasters hamper sustainable development and stretch national capabilities. While DRR investments typically rely on government budgets and external loans, innovations such as green bonds have emerged to secure funding. Conversely, financing for residual risk has attracted significant global attention through initiatives like the Global Shield against Climate Risks, launched at COP28. Despite these advancements, PAF coverage remains low relative to the immense scale of funding required for disaster response, leaving many countries with a significant residual financing gap.
A note on terminology
The report highlights the varying definitions of DRM terms across different disciplines. It distinguishes between disaster risk financing (DRF) and PAF. DRF is defined as a system of budgetary and financial mechanisms arranged before a shock to pay for specific risks, including prevention. PAF is a specific subset of DRF that is approved in advance and guaranteed for release when pre-identified triggers are met. This research uses ‘disaster risk reduction’ to mean ex ante measures taken in advance of a shock to reduce existing risk and avoid creating new risk, which is a narrower definition than the Sendai Framework.
Research methodology
The research assessed national policy frameworks in South Africa, Tonga, and Pakistan, selected for their diverse geographies and established public DRF and DRM policies. The evaluation was based on six criteria, including the context of broader DRM frameworks, the use of quantified risk assessments, and the assignment of clear roles. To supplement these deep dives, the research examined DRF strategies from ten additional countries, including Colombia, Indonesia, Jamaica, Malawi, and the Solomon Islands, providing a comprehensive overview of how principles are applied in practice.
Analysis
The analysis indicates that while the symbiotic relationship between DRR and PAF is endorsed in high-level policy, it is weakly leveraged in practice. Only Tonga bases its DRF strategy on probabilistic risk modelling, drawing on data from the Pacific Catastrophe Risk Assessment and Financing Initiative (PCRAFI) to model assets including residential, industrial, and infrastructure buildings. In contrast, South Africa and Pakistan emphasise spatial disaster risk assessments over monetary risk metrics. This lack of quantitative financial data often limits the estimation of contingent liabilities and funding gaps.
Institutional roles are most clearly defined when DRM is mainstreamed into national budgeting. Pakistan is the only country reviewed that has set indicative percentage allocations, aiming for 1% to 2% of development budgets for DRR initiatives. Dedicated funds have been established in some regions, such as Tonga’s National Emergency Fund, which receives an annual appropriation of approximately TOP 5 million (USD 2 million). However, many countries still lack clear budgetary commitments and strong links between national and subnational financing responsibilities.
Costing of strategies remains inconsistent. Tonga’s Joint National Action Plan (JNAP) 2 is estimated to cost USD 147 million over ten years, yet its DRF intentions are not costed. Pakistan’s Nationally Determined Contribution 3.0 indicates a total implementation cost of USD 560 million between 2025 and 2035. While most DRF strategies qualitatively apply a risk-layered approach, they rarely incorporate DRR options into their cost-effectiveness analysis, hindering the ability to compare ex ante and ex post spending.
Findings and reflections
Coordination between DRR and DRF is often recognised in national policies but is infrequently delivered in practice. Analytical gaps regarding risk metrics and contingent liabilities prevent governments from securing a cost-efficient balance of expenditure. The research reflects that governments should consider preparing DRR and DRF strategies in tandem to maximise resilience gains. Strengthening disaster damage and loss records is also essential to help build awareness of specific vulnerabilities and protect spending during periods of limited disaster losses.