How marginalization shapes mineral mining impacts on local populations: A review of evidence and mechanisms
This systematic review examines how mineral mining interacts with social vulnerabilities to drive unequal outcomes. It identifies mechanisms—such as biological susceptibility and unequal power—that disproportionately affect the health of women and children. The report advocates for mechanism-focused governance to ensure equitable outcomes during critical mineral extraction expansion.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Mining is one of the most environmentally and socially disruptive human activities, causing soil, air, and water contamination alongside landscape degradation. Its impacts extend to profound transformations in local livelihoods, land tenure, and access to natural resources. In many regions, particularly in the Global South, mining expansion is driven by non-local demand for minerals, frequently bringing extractive activities into the territories of Indigenous peoples and other marginalised groups. Communities near mining operations often face negative outcomes, such as pollution-related health burdens and social displacement, while receiving limited benefits like employment and revenues. This study clarifies how mining activities interact with and compound existing marginalisation to drive unequal outcomes, specifically focusing on critical minerals essential for global decarbonisation strategies.
Methodology
This review followed a systematic evidence-mapping approach and qualitative synthesis, adhering to the protocol registered in PROCEED. Researchers conducted bibliographic searches in Scopus and Web of Science Core Collections, screening more than 6,600 relevant articles published between 2018 and 2023. The scope included 145 studies focusing on social systems influenced by current or proposed informal and formal subsoil mineral mining. The review excluded hydrocarbons and common materials like sand, gravel, and rock mining. The evidence base was coded for variables including mineral type, mining stage, and targeted marginalised populations. A knowledge cluster focused on physical health impacts among populations marginalised by gender and age was selected for in-depth qualitative synthesis, involving eleven peer-reviewed articles evaluated using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool.
Results
The evidence base spans 45 countries, with the highest concentration of studies in Africa (77) and the Americas (42). Ghana was the most represented country, followed by Brazil and the Democratic Republic of Congo. Gold mining dominated the research (66%), followed by copper (13%), with 26 different minerals represented in total. Most studies focused on the operational stage of mining. The evidence was nearly equally split between artisanal and industrial mines, with 54% of studies focusing on formal operations and 46% on informal mining. Marginalised populations were primarily identified by gender (43%), ethnicity (26%), and age group (26%).
Qualitative synthesis of health impacts revealed that children were almost exclusively negatively affected (96%), experiencing issues such as neurotoxicity, renal toxicity, and metabolic disruption. Women experienced both negative (70%) and positive (30%) outcomes, with some benefiting from increased income and employment opportunities despite facing higher exposure to contaminants and sexual exploitation. The synthesis identified five underlying mechanisms driving these differential outcomes: biological susceptibility, restricted access to resources, unequal power relations, cultural reliance on specific foods, and social status. For children, biological susceptibility during sensitive developmental stages was a primary driver of harm. For women, structural inequalities in land access and healthcare increased their vulnerability to environmental hazards.
Discussion
The findings indicate that differential outcomes are shaped not only by the specific mineral extracted but by the mechanisms through which mining interacts with existing vulnerabilities. This aligns with environmental justice theory, which suggests that environmental harms are distributed along structural patterns of exclusion. Contamination of water, soil, and food translates into disproportionate health consequences for children due to their higher biological absorption rates. For women, gendered responsibilities related to water collection and caregiving increase exposure to hazardous materials.
Policy and planning efforts should aim to address these underlying mechanisms. Key interventions include securing land and resource rights, closing gender- and age-based access gaps, and improving health protections through enforceable standards. Governance should move beyond voluntary corporate social responsibility to incorporate mechanism-focused approaches that require regulators to demonstrate how risks to marginalised groups are prevented and remedied. Frameworks such as the IPCC Risk Framework and the European Environment Agency’s causal models can help identify these pathways, provided they are linked to independent monitoring and transparent grievance mechanisms.
Conclusions
The rapid expansion of critical mineral extraction presents an urgent need to ensure that the transition to low-carbon technologies does not reproduce historical inequities. While specific evidence for many critical minerals remains limited, broader mining research offers vital lessons. Recurring mechanisms, such as biological susceptibility and unequal power relations, provide actionable entry points for more equitable mining governance. Embedding these mechanisms into research and policy can support the early identification of risks and strengthen safeguards for marginalised populations. Recognising these pathways is essential for breaking feedback loops that sustain marginalisation and for ensuring that the global energy transition contributes to both environmental sustainability and social justice.