Attribution science and climate change litigation in India
This research examines the integration of attribution science into Indian climate litigation. It proposes the Weiss scale to bridge scientific uncertainty and legal standards of proof. Through eight landmark judgments, the study demonstrates how a ‘scientifically legal’ lexicon can enhance judicial consistency and establish accountability for climate-related harms.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Climate change is legally disruptive and polycentric, involving complex scientific-causal chains of evidence. In litigation, attribution science serves as an evidentiary tool to ascertain responsibility, accountability, and liability. It evaluates the relative contributions of multiple causal factors to observed changes in climate variables, such as global surface temperature or extreme weather events. While globally recognised, the Indian judiciary currently uses scientific evidence in an unstructured or fragmented manner, often without clearly labelling it as attribution science. This ad-hoc reliance carries significant drawbacks, including potential inconsistencies in judicial outcomes and a lack of legal certainty.
The science of climate attribution and IPCC framework
Attribution studies synthesise historical observations and climate models to determine human influence. The IPCC identifies four attribution categories: trend, source, event, and impact attribution. The Sixth Assessment Report (AR6) states it is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean, and land. The IPCC utilises probabilistic forecasting and a calibrated language of confidence levels (ranging from very low to very high) and likelihood terms to convey uncertainty. For instance, ‘virtually certain’ corresponds to a probability of over 99%, while ‘likely’ covers 66–100%.
Weiss scale: integrating scientific certainty and legal standard of proof
The research proposes the adoption of the ‘Weiss scale’, a ten-level scale correlating scientific certainty with legal standards of proof. This framework addresses the challenge of translating probabilistic scientific data into the legal thresholds required for judicial reasoning. For example, Level 9 on the Weiss scale corresponds to ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’, while Level 5 represents the ‘preponderance of the evidence’. This ‘scientifically legal’ lexicon helps generalist judges judge the merits of opposing scientific arguments. In India, where climate data is often characterised by disparities in measurements and inconsistent methodology, this scale provides a fixed calibration point for attributing legal causation.
The method
The authors employed three filters to analyse Indian climate cases: a subject-matter filter for judgments after 2013 involving climate harm; a scientific evidence filter for assessments linked to attribution; and a calibrated language filter based on the IPCC AR6. The study also utilises the ‘fraction of attributable risk’ (FAR) to measure the proportion of risk attributable to a specific cause, particularly in cases where climate change is an ancillary rather than core issue.
Applying the Weiss scale to Indian climate litigation
The research analysed eight illustrative judgments. In the Rohtang Pass case, the National Green Tribunal (NGT) linked glacial melting to black carbon, noting that 0.40% of retreat was attributed to its impact. This was mapped to a ‘substantial and credible’ threshold (Level 6). In In re: News item “India’s Sinking Island”, the NGT assigned a ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’ standard (Level 9) regarding anthropogenic forcing and sea-level rise. In the Dairy livestock case, the tribunal reviewed a study showing Indian livestock released 15.3 million tonnes of methane, using a ‘clearly showing’ standard (Level 7) to justify regulatory intervention.
In M.K. Ranjitsinh v Union of India, the Supreme Court established a link between general climate harm and constitutional rights to a level ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ (Level 9). However, regarding the mortality of the Great Indian Bustard (GIB) due to transmission lines, the court applied a ‘preponderance of the evidence’ standard (Level 5), noting mortality was ‘partly attributed’ to the infrastructure. Other cases, such as the Joshimath disaster, highlighted the vulnerability of mountain ecosystems, where glacial retreat was considered a main influencing factor, aligned with Level 6 on the Weiss scale.
Conclusion
The analysis reveals a growing judicial willingness in India to assume causation between human-induced emissions and localised harms. However, without a cohesive approach, outcomes remain unpredictable. The extended Weiss scale is proposed as an interdisciplinary roadmap to help evaluate evidence for proving causality. Systematically integrating this scale into adjudicative processes will enhance transparency, predictability, and fairness while developing context-specific benchmarks that reflect India’s constitutional safeguards and public-interest litigation traditions.