Impact goals
This report outlines a consensus on setting impact goals based on nine core principles. It establishes a shared foundation for understanding impact across dimensions like depth, scale, and duration. The framework emphasises managing positive and negative effects separately, accounting for risk, and specifying contributions within wider systems.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Context
As the number of individuals and organisations working to achieve impact grows, there is a corresponding need to understand mutual expectations and agree on methodologies for measuring and managing performance. To find consensus, the Impact Management Project has facilitated virtual and in-person conversations across different disciplines, geographies, and worldviews. This document summarises the emerging consensus from these sessions, which covered topics such as beneficiaries, societal issues, outcomes, system change, additionality, consequences, and user journeys across various sectors including investment managers, corporates, and social enterprises.
#1 A shared foundation for understanding ‘impact’ – and therefore expressing our impact goals – enables us to work together
Regardless of the specific decision-making frameworks used, which may be proprietary or ‘off-the-shelf’, there is a shared desire to observe a common foundation for understanding impact. This foundation allows for the description of impact goals and management against them. A shared understanding enables stakeholders to work together across value chains, from those experiencing impact on the ground to delivery models, intermediaries, asset owners, and policymakers.
#2 Our experience of impact has multiple dimensions
Impact is experienced through several dimensions. First, the ‘what’ dimension relates an effect to a specific outcome and assesses its importance based on personal preferences, expert opinion, or public consensus (such as the Sustainable Development Goals or Social Progress Index). Second, the ‘how much’ dimension judges the scale of an effect by considering its depth (the extent to which it drives an outcome), its scale (the number of people affected), and its duration (how long the effect lasts). Third, the ‘who’ dimension defines the recipient of the effect, such as a farmer in Nigeria or the earth’s atmosphere, and assesses how well-served they already are regarding the outcome.
#3 Our impact goals also include the risk we are willing to take that the effect is different from our expectation
Impact goals must account for the risk that actual effects may deviate from expectations. For instance, an innovative health service might inadvertently worsen physical health or, conversely, improve it significantly more than anticipated. Several risk factors, such as evidence risk, external risk, and stakeholder participation risk, should be considered when setting these goals to understand the potential for unexpected outcomes.
#4 Our impact goals always include trying to prevent significant negative effects of our delivery model(s), while our intentions and constraints inform which significant positive effects we include in our goals
Goal setting involves judging whether effects are significant and determining the likely contribution to them. It is essential to set goals to prevent significant negative effects, especially those where the contribution is making the situation worse or not improving it. Intentions, constraints, and financial goals then inform the selection of significant positive effects to increase. As actual significant effects on people and the planet are understood, delivery models or the goals themselves may be re-designed or re-set.
#5 We set goals based on the significant effects on people and planet of a delivery model, regardless of whether they are generated by its products/services, its distribution chain, its operations or its supply-chain
Effects generated by a delivery model’s distribution chain, operations, or supply chain are not necessarily more or less significant than those from its products or services. Management judgements should consider if an effect is ‘significant’ and if the organisation’s contribution is likely to improve the current state. For example, a large business may find its supply chain impacts more significant than a small business would, making it compelling to set goals for those effects through its supply chain.
#6 We always want an effect related to an important positive outcome to be deep, to occur for many people and to last for a long time
While stakeholders generally prefer deep, widespread, and long-lasting effects, no single driver of significance is necessarily more important than others. Opinions vary on whether a deep effect for a few is better than a marginal effect for many. In practice, all data regarding the depth, scale, and duration are analysed to make an overall judgement on the significance of the effect.
#7 When we set goals related to our ‘contribution’, we do so from the perspective of where we sit in a value chain
Investors or funders set goals regarding the contribution of the delivery models they support, but they also set goals for their own contribution as investors or funders to enable those delivery models to generate impact for people and the planet. This reflects the different roles stakeholders play within the impact value chain.
#8 When we are expressing goals in relation to our effects on “a system”, we try to be specific about which actors and relationships in a system we are referring to
Actors in wider systems generate effects for others through relationships. These effects are often institutionalised in organisational forms (like markets), widespread social or cultural norms, or government policies. Goal setting should describe significant effects on relevant systems by being specific about the actors and relationships involved, expressed in terms of institutions such as specific markets, norms, or policies.
#9 We manage significant positive and negative effects on different groups of people and the planet separately, rather than assuming that our significant positive effects means we can ignore significant negative ones
Positive and negative effects do not cancel each other out, whether within the same group of people, between different groups, or between people and the planet. Judgements must be made on whether achieving a positive effect is worth a temporary negative one, but goals should still be set to mitigate negative effects over time. Note that positive and negative effects can only be ‘netted off’ when expressed in the same unit, such as carbon emissions.