Measuring the impact of impact measurement
This research evaluates the private returns of impact measurement through two experiments in India. It finds that social enterprises receiving hands-on measurement support double their revenue growth and capital raising. Investors strongly prefer quantified metrics over qualitative narratives, suggesting rigorous data is essential for effective impact capital allocation.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Over the last two decades, the movement to combine social impact with corporate interests has grown significantly, with leading estimates suggesting that impact investors now control more than USD 1.5 trillion in assets. Social enterprises are estimated to generate over USD 2 trillion in annual revenue worldwide. Despite this scale, impact investing faces a measurement problem: while profits are easily quantified through accounting and taxation, social impact is often costly to measure, difficult to compare across firms, and typically communicated through qualitative narratives. This research addresses the core economic question of whether there are private returns to measuring social returns. The study employs two experiments to investigate how impact measurement affects firm growth, access to capital, and investor demand.
Experiment #1: the impact of impact measurement
The first experiment was conducted in partnership with Villgro, India’s largest incubator of social enterprises. It involved 163 participating firms across various sectors, including agribusiness, health, energy, and education. The study was designed to isolate the incremental effect of moving from impact measurement and management (IMM) training to actual implementation. All participating firms were offered a seven-session IMM course, but they were randomly assigned to either a control group or a treatment group that received hands-on implementation support.
Impact measurement and management course
The core training programme ran in seven two-hour Zoom sessions. It covered three main components: outlining a theory of change, introducing measurement frameworks such as IRIS+ and the Lean Data approach, and teaching tactics for communicating impact to stakeholders. This exposure to IMM concepts, language, and certification was common to both experimental arms to ensure that any observed differences were due to implementation support rather than classroom exposure alone.
Intervention
Treatment firms received personalised, hands-on support from Villgro representatives to operationalise impact measurement. This included several one-on-one sessions to select an IMM framework, define specific indicators, and plan stakeholder outreach. The research team then conducted surveys of the treatment firms’ customers, employees, and suppliers. The results were synthesised into a personalised impact report summarising stakeholder surplus measures, which provided a quantitative evaluation of the value created for different stakeholders beyond their next-best alternatives.
Results
The intervention had a substantial impact on both revenue growth and access to capital. Treatment group firms experienced an additional USD 20,000 in revenue growth compared to the control group, effectively doubling the growth rate. Access to capital also improved significantly, with treated firms raising an additional USD 43,000 in external funding, another doubling relative to control firms. The researchers observed a distributional shift in both revenue and capital raised, indicating that the results were not driven by a small number of outliers. No statistically significant effect was found on whether firms reached profitability, consistent with the fact that many early-stage startups prioritise growth over short-run profits.
Mechanisms
The researchers suggest two primary channels through which impact measurement affects firm growth. Internally, the process of engaging stakeholders and collecting stakeholder-level data generates business intelligence, helping firms learn which customer segments and use cases generate the most value. Externally, quantified impact metrics increase credibility with investors. These two channels may reinforce each other, as better internal decision-making improves growth prospects, making firms more attractive to external funders, while additional capital enables firms to reach more customers.
Experiment #2: investor demand for impact measurement
To isolate investor demand for quantified impact information, the researchers conducted a companion field experiment with 223 early-stage investors with experience in Indian startups. Investors were recruited through professional networks and a commercial survey platform. They were shown synthetic company profiles and asked to rate their investment interest on a 1–7 scale. The experiment randomised how a startup’s social impact was communicated: via baseline customer demographics, a qualitative narrative statement, or quantified customer-surplus metrics.
Results
The findings show that investor interest is highly responsive to quantified evidence. Moving a startup from below- to above-median customer surplus increased investor interest by 0.42 points, a magnitude comparable to the premium for being profitable (0.56 points). In contrast, generic qualitative impact statements had a small and statistically insignificant effect on investor interest. This suggests that investors do not reward impact language itself, but rather respond to credible, quantified evidence of social returns.
Conclusion
The research concludes that rigorous impact measurement is a critical component of the infrastructure required for the effective allocation of impact capital. By providing causal evidence on the private returns to implementing these practices, the study demonstrates that measurement can meaningfully shape both firm growth and capital allocation. The findings suggest that the form of impact communication matters significantly, with quantified metrics being decision-relevant for investors in a way that qualitative narratives are not.