Study to support the fitness check of the Polluter Pays Principle
This study evaluates the implementation of the Polluter Pays Principle in EU environmental policy between 2014 and 2023. It finds that while the principle is well-integrated regarding pollution prevention and control, strengthening is needed for administrative and environmental damage costs to improve overall effectiveness and market stability.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
This report presents findings from the supporting study to the fitness check of the implementation of the Polluter Pays Principle (PPP) in EU environmental policy and selected funding programmes. The study examined the effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, coherence, and EU added value of PPP application between 2014 and 2023. The PPP is applied where polluters bear the costs of their pollution, including the costs of measures taken to prevent, control, and remedy pollution, along with the wider societal costs of environmental damage. For the purposes of this analysis, costs were defined across three categories: pollution prevention and control costs, administrative and enforcement measures, and environmental damage costs borne by wider society.
Methodology
Evidence gathering for this study involved desk research, public consultations, targeted interviews, and stakeholder workshops. Desk research included a legal review of policy provisions, a qualitative literature assessment, and a quantitative assessment for indicators relating to costs and pollution trends. A total of 83 items of legislation were reviewed. Consultation activities comprised a twelve-week public consultation with 268 respondents from 27 countries, targeted interviews with 30 expert stakeholders, and two stakeholder workshops in 2023 involving competent authorities, industry associations, NGOs, and research organisations.
What was the expected outcome of the intervention
The intervention logic for the PPP relies on addressing market failures where the costs of pollution prevention and societal damage are not fully reflected in prices. The objective is to provide price signals to efficiently reduce pollution and ensure environmental policies are implemented in a fair manner. The outputs include ensuring that polluters pay for prevention, control, administrative measures, and environmental damage, including allowable residual pollution or accidental pollution.
How has the situation evolved over the evaluation period?
National expenditure on environmental protection (NEEP) by EU27 Member States was estimated at €340 billion in 2022. High-level analysis indicates that corporations and households, rather than national governments, bear the majority of this expenditure. Spending has remained stable as a proportion of GDP during the evaluation period. At the EU27 level, the largest proportion of spending is by the corporate sector, which accounted for EUR 180.2 billion or 53% of the total in 2022. However, external costs remain significant; industrial air emissions between 2012 and 2021 had an estimated external cost between €2.7 and €4.3 trillion, averaging between €268 and €428 billion per year.
Evaluation findings
The effectiveness of PPP application varies by cost type and policy area. It is generally well implemented in policies addressing pollution prevention and control, covering 48 of 72 policies (67%). However, gaps exist in administrative and enforcement measures, where costs are partially or fully borne by competent authorities in 44% of reviewed policies. Environmental damage is not addressed by legislative provisions in 46 policies, representing 64% of the total. While EU action facilitates market stability and harmonisation, significant variations exist in the implementation of market-based instruments (MBIs) between Member States. For instance, internalisation rates for air pollution and greenhouse gases reach only 44% economy-wide across the EU, with wide variation between sectors. Environmental taxes accounted for approximately 2.2% of GDP in 2021, with revenue from energy taxes making up 78% of that total.
What are the conclusions and lessons learned?
The study concludes that the PPP remains highly relevant to the needs of the EU as established in the European Green Deal. EU action facilitates market stability and has contributed to minimal variation between Member States in the share of national expenditure on environmental protection relative to GDP. Opportunities exist to strengthen implementation by establishing minimum standards for costs polluters pay and by using horizontal policy mechanisms to address shortcomings in internalising environmental damage costs. Challenges persist, including the conflict between the PPP and environmentally harmful subsidies (EHS). Fossil fuel subsidies in EU Member States were estimated at EUR 122 billion in 2022, doubling from the previous year. Addressing these subsidies and closing implementation gaps for legacy and diffuse pollution remains essential for a fair and just transition.