Getting started with systems mapping & impact management
This report explores integrating systems mapping into impact management for investors. It outlines qualitative and semi-quantitative approaches to visualising complex systems. By identifying leverage points and non-linear causal pathways, investors can better assess impact risks and refine theories of change at both investment and portfolio levels.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Part 1: introduction to systems mapping
Systems mapping is defined as the process of constructing visual models of a system. These maps consist of elements, causal relationships between those elements, and system boundaries. Elements, also referred to as nodes, are dynamic nouns that interact within a system, ranging from physical infrastructure and GHGs to human behaviour and beliefs. Every element in a map must be connected to at least one other, meaning it either affects or is affected by another part of the system.
1. What is systems mapping
The core components of these maps are ‘directed’ causal relationships, often shown as one-directional arrows. These lines communicate critical information about the nature of the relationship, such as whether a connection is positive (where an increase in one element leads to an increase in another) or negative. They can also indicate time horizons, the strength of an effect, and the likelihood that one element will influence another. Naming a subject as a system implies it will be analysed through its component parts and their interactions.
2. Approaches to systems mapping: the qualitative-quantitative spectrum
Systems mapping approaches are categorised along a spectrum from qualitative to quantitative. Qualitative systems maps do not assign numerical values to elements or relationships. Instead, they are utilised to analyse a system’s structure and identify leverage points. These maps are particularly useful for aggregating information from disparate sources, such as stakeholder engagements and market research, to facilitate dialogue and build alignment within an organisation.
To identify leverage points within qualitative maps, practitioners often conduct connectivity analyses, which identify elements affecting the highest number of other components. They also look for feedback loops. A positive or ‘reinforcing’ feedback loop occurs when an increase in an element eventually results in a further increase in that same element. Conversely, a ‘negative’ or ‘stabilising’ feedback loop occurs when an increase leads to a subsequent decrease, creating a self-correcting mechanism.
Semi-quantitative systems maps take the additional step of assigning values to the strength or likelihood of causal relationships. This allows practitioners to consider how changes propagate through a system by comparing different causal pathways. While they offer a more predictive function, they carry interpretive risks and should be treated as thinking tools rather than precise forecasts. Quantitative systems maps, which assign values to both elements and relationships, are significantly more resource-intensive and require specialised technical training.
Part 2: systems mapping for investors
Impact investors are drawn to systems mapping to better understand the complex social and economic systems in which stakeholder outcomes are embedded. Traditional ‘theory of change’ (ToC) models often rely on a sequential, linear logic that might oversimplify reality. Systems mapping serves as a powerful complement to ToCs by integrating the dynamic environment surrounding these outcomes.
1. Systems mapping and theories of change
Traditional theories of change can occasionally overlook critical impact risks. These include ‘external risk’—the probability that external factors disrupt an organisation’s ability to deliver impact—and ‘unexpected impact risk’, which involves significant unforeseen positive or negative effects. Linear models may reinforce an innate optimism, causing organisations to overestimate their scale of influence while underestimating external systemic factors. Systems mapping offers a structured way to collect and examine these often-marginalised contextual factors.
2. Integrating systems mapping into impact investors’ theories of change
Investors can apply these techniques at both the individual investment level and the portfolio level to refine their impact strategies and management practices.
Investment-level
At the investment level, systems mapping can recast the development of a theory of change as a structured examination of impact risk. During due diligence, investors can use semi-quantitative maps to assess knowledge gaps and identify what they can or cannot anticipate about an investment’s effect on stakeholders. This approach moves beyond simply articulating intentions to assessing the likelihood of intended and unintended impacts.
The strength of a map’s evidence base is often measured through stakeholder engagement, following the ‘multiple biases’ principle. This principle suggests that while individual perspectives may be biased, a map becomes increasingly objective as it integrates a diversity of viewpoints. Centring stakeholder engagement is both tactically necessary for well-informed decisions and ethically desirable for addressing power imbalances.
Portfolio-level
Portfolio-level systems maps are typically qualitative and focus on identifying high-leverage points where resource allocation can best advance impact goals. These maps inform fund strategy, pipeline sourcing, and screening. Investment-level and portfolio-level mapping are mutually reinforcing processes; portfolio maps generate hypotheses for specific deals, while the results of individual investment analyses are used to update and refine the broader portfolio-level model.
Conclusion
While systems mapping is currently a frontier topic with few concrete case studies, it offers a promising avenue for impact management. It provides a structured method to embrace complexity, reminding investors of the limits of their knowledge while offering tools to better achieve stated goals. Ultimately, systems mapping changes the ‘mapper’ as much as it changes the system, fostering a deeper understanding of stakeholder contexts and systemic interdependencies.