Transition framework for financial institutions: What really matters to drive real-economy outcomes
This research outlines a transition framework for financial institutions, prioritising real-economy outcomes over process-based metrics. It argues that financing should be the strategic backbone, moving beyond misleading emissions targets. The framework advocates for differentiated influence channels, the integration of external factors, and robust ex-post monitoring through attribution analysis.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Foreword
This white paper presents the findings of research led by the PARC (Paris Agreement Research Commons) Foundation to assess the transition and mitigation performance of financial institutions (FIs). The work builds on broader research with contributions from the Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment (CCSI) and support from Arc. The foundation aims to align financial systems with climate objectives and help economic actors achieve the goals of the Paris Agreement.
Context
In recent years, the financial ecosystem has seen a multiplication of data tools and frameworks. However, this has often led to confusion and overshadowed the primary objective: financing the decarbonisation of the real economy. Current mainstream approaches focus heavily on financed emissions targets, which fall short of capturing an FI’s true impact and can be misleading. Goodhart’s Law suggests that when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure; indicators can be manipulated once they become strategic targets. Many methodologies operate at the level of disclosure, turning reporting into a compliance exercise rather than a driver of strategic transformation. There is a need to refocus on the actions, levers, and metrics that most effectively contribute to real-economy decarbonisation.
Our approach: what & how
The PARC Foundation developed four dedicated frameworks tailored to banks, asset managers, asset owners, and insurers. These frameworks focus on the contribution of FIs to financing the transition, encompassing both impact alignment (exposure to transitioning assets) and impact generation (supporting real-economy decarbonisation). This approach is not risk-based, as climate risk scenarios do not automatically translate into transition-aligned capital reallocation. The frameworks use outcome-oriented metrics, prioritising outputs and impacts over process-based metrics. Each framework follows a progressive logic from governance and strategy through to implementation and measurable outcomes.
Emissions targets have been misleading
While financed emissions data are critical, current target-setting methodologies often focus too heavily on portfolio emissions at the expense of other levers. Financed emissions rely on monetary attribution factors, such as Enterprise Value Including Cash (EVIC), which introduce significant volatility. Reported emissions can fluctuate due to market valuations or interest rates rather than actual emissions performance. This decoupling means a market rally can artificially ‘deflate’ carbon intensity. The report suggests a distinction between alignment and impact, noting that portfolio reallocation alone does not guarantee changes in corporate behaviour. Emissions metrics should function as lagging indicators to validate outcomes over time, complemented by financing and engagement targets.
Financing must become the backbone
Capital allocation is the primary lever for FIs to influence the transition. Frameworks should shift from portfolio alignment to portfolio contribution across three levels: Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA), financial products, and asset-level classification. SAA represents the highest level of leverage, where climate risks and opportunities must be integrated into long-term Capital Market Assumptions. Financial products, such as green bonds and sustainability-linked bonds, serve as transmission mechanisms. Assessing these products requires considering their additionality, especially in emerging markets and developing economies (EMDEs). Finally, robust taxonomies and maturity scales are needed at the execution layer to categorise assets based on their transition readiness and avoid ‘transition washing’.
Channels of influence in driving the transition
Mechanisms of influence differ across FI types. For insurers, influence extends through distribution channels and claims management, where lower-carbon repair practices can be promoted. Asset managers can influence the real economy by engaging with index providers to advocate for climate-tilted weightings. Asset owners can exert influence through investment mandates and escalation policies with asset managers. The report highlights a missing piece: how FIs coordinate at an ecosystem level to expand investable markets for climate solutions. This requires coordinated action between financiers, policymakers, and infrastructure providers to address barriers like grid capacity or insurance coverage.
External factors: mapping enablers and barriers
Transition feasibility depends on external factors beyond an FI’s control, such as policy strategy, technological development, and resource availability. Frameworks must integrate these enablers and barriers to ensure transition performance is anchored in a real-world context. Scenario analysis can define assumptions about these factors against which strategies can be tested. Developing ex-post information on barriers encountered by FIs and their counterparts can explain why certain targets failed to materialise and identify where policy intervention is required to enable an effective transition.
Ex-post monitoring: after the talk comes the walk
There is a significant ambition-credibility gap between climate commitments and historical performance. Stronger ex-post monitoring is required to verify if commitments have been effectively implemented. This includes attribution analysis to isolate the share of emissions reductions linked to real-economy decarbonisation versus portfolio composition or financial fluctuations. The report suggests four categories of drivers for portfolio emissions changes: asset-level emissions, portfolio composition (e.g., divestment), financial metrics, and data quality. This framework allows FIs to learn from results and adjust capital allocation and engagement strategies accordingly in future cycles.