Access to remedy and decent work
This report examines access to remedy for labour rights violations within business operations. It outlines the roles of states and enterprises under international frameworks like the UNGPs. It explores various grievance mechanisms, systemic barriers for workers, and the ILO’s initiatives to strengthen labour justice systems and dispute resolution globally.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Enterprises are the driving force of economies and contribute to social progress, yet their activities can have adverse impacts on people, the environment and society. To achieve sustainability across economic, social and environmental dimensions, an enabling environment is required. Both enterprises and governments have complementary roles and responsibilities in promoting and realising responsible business conduct (RBC). The leading international frameworks include the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs), the ILO Tripartite Declaration of Principles concerning Multinational Enterprises and Social Policy (MNE Declaration), and the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Responsible Business Conduct. The UNGPs consist of three pillars: (1) The State duty to protect human rights; (2) The corporate responsibility to respect human rights; and (3) Access to remedy.
What does access to remedy mean in the context of business and human rights?
Access to remedy refers to the ability of individuals, workers and communities whose human rights have been adversely impacted by business operations to seek and obtain fair, effective and timely redress. It is addressed in Article 8 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and is a foundational principle within the State’s duty to protect. Guiding Principle 25 mandates that States must take appropriate steps to ensure those affected have access to effective remedy through judicial, administrative, legislative or other appropriate means. Access to remedy is intrinsically related to access to labour justice, which is central to the ILO mandate. Regional human rights systems, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, also establish enforceable rights to a fair trial and effective remedies.
What are the main characteristics and implications of labour-related grievances in the context of business operations?
A workplace grievance is defined as a concern, complaint or dissatisfaction raised by an individual or group of workers regarding matters such as treatment by a supervisor, working conditions, pay or discipline. It generally does not encompass collective claims for modifying employment conditions. A labour dispute is a broader concept referring to disagreements arising from employment relationships that may be individual or collective. These include “rights disputes” concerning existing legal or contractual entitlements and “interests disputes” related to the creation of new rights, often emerging from breakdowns in collective bargaining. Individual disputes typically concern job termination, wage claims, hours and discrimination, while collective disputes often involve the status and recognition of trade unions.
Who should ensure access to remedy?
States bear the primary duty to ensure access to remedy for those affected by business-related human rights abuses. This involves establishing effective judicial and non-judicial mechanisms capable of providing appropriate redress. Businesses have a responsibility, appropriate to their size and circumstances, to have processes in place to enable the remediation of adverse impacts they cause or contribute to, and to cooperate in remediation processes. The MNE Declaration recommends that multinational enterprises use their leverage to enable remediation and ensures workers can submit grievances without suffering prejudice.
What are the main mechanisms to provide access to remedy?
The UNGPs recognise three categories of mechanisms: (i) State-based judicial mechanisms; (ii) State-based non-judicial grievance mechanisms; and (iii) non-State-based grievance mechanisms. Judicial mechanisms, such as labour courts and tribunals, are viewed as the primary avenue for remedy and are essential for the rule of law. State-based non-judicial mechanisms include Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) services like mediation, conciliation and voluntary arbitration. Non-State-based mechanisms are administered by non-governmental actors, including businesses, industry groups and multistakeholder initiatives. These can provide faster, more flexible ways to address grievances, particularly at the operational level.
What are the main complementarities between the different mechanisms to access effective remedy?
The different mechanisms function in a mutually reinforcing manner rather than as substitutes. ILO standards emphasise the complementarity of proceedings between judicial and non-judicial mechanisms to ensure workers have multiple avenues to seek redress. ADR procedures can serve to filter disputes before they reach judicial institutions. This layered approach forms a remedial ecosystem, ensuring that remedies are both accessible and effective while safeguarding rights to judicial recourse. International labour standards also call for the establishment of appropriate workplace-level grievance procedures to address issues early.
What are the main barriers that workers typically face to access remedy?
Numerous barriers persist, particularly for workers in vulnerable situations. These include financial constraints such as high litigation costs, procedural hurdles like lengthy and complex processes, and a lack of awareness regarding rights and available mechanisms. Migrant and informal workers may face additional language barriers and cultural norms that discourage complaints. Fear of retaliation is a significant deterrent. Furthermore, legal exclusions often leave certain groups, such as domestic or agricultural workers, without access to remedy. The digital divide also hinders access as many systems become increasingly digitalised.
What are the key elements of access to remedy?
Access to effective remedy has both procedural and substantive dimensions. Procedural aspects relate to the availability, efficiency, accessibility and fairness of the process. This includes the provision of legal aid, simplified procedures, and set timelines for processing applications. Substantive elements concern the actual outcomes and measures provided to victims, ensuring redress is meaningful. Remedies may include apologies, restitution, rehabilitation, financial or non-financial compensation, punitive sanctions, and injunctions to prevent future harm. ILO standards specifically provide for remedies such as reinstatement and the right to resign with compensation.
What are the effectiveness criteria of grievance mechanisms?
UNGP Principle 31 provides criteria for non-judicial grievance mechanisms to be considered effective: legitimate, accessible, predictable, equitable, transparent, rights-compatible and a source of continuous learning. For operational-level mechanisms, they must also be based on engagement and dialogue. The ILO has adopted Principles of Effectiveness for labour dispute institutions, which include efficiency, speediness, accessibility, fairness, equality, accountability, independence, impartiality, professionalism and enforcement. For non-judicial institutions, three additional principles apply: voluntarism, confidentiality and prevention.
How does the ILO support access to remedy?
The ILO operationalises access to labour justice through technical assistance, research and partnerships. Its supervisory bodies assess whether national laws provide effective enforcement mechanisms. The ILO provides technical assistance and advisory services to member States to strengthen LDPR systems and offers a diagnostic tool for self-assessment. Training and capacity building are provided for judges, conciliators and social partners. Specific initiatives include the BetterWork programme, currently conducting initiatives in Bangladesh and Cambodia aimed at strengthening workers’ access to remedy in the garment sector, with a focus on gender-based violence and harassment (GBVH).