Cheaper, faster, better: A formula for cleantech scaling success
This McKinsey Sustainability report examines success factors for scaling clean technology. Analysing over 11,000 companies, it identifies that top performers deliver solutions that are cheaper, faster, and better than conventional alternatives. The research highlights structural shifts in funding, identifies common pitfalls, and outlines forces shaping the sector’s future.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Cleantech is maturing, and the real challenge is scaling
The cleantech sector is entering a more disciplined phase where capital flows towards companies capable of demonstrating real-world performance. Since 2015, more than 11,000 analysed cleantech start-ups and scale-ups have raised over $480 billion in total funding across equity, debt, and grants. In the postboom era of 2023–25, average annual funding reached approximately $70 billion, which is roughly 3.8 times the preboom average. Despite headlines suggesting a retreat, funding momentum has held, with postboom annual funding decreasing by only 10 per cent relative to the boom era.
Structural shifts define this new period, including a rise in average deal sizes from under $5 million in 2015 to $16 million in 2025. This reflects an investor pivot towards fewer, larger, later-stage investments in companies ready to deploy at scale. The financing mix has also evolved; debt now accounts for roughly 25 per cent of postboom funding, up from approximately 10 per cent in previous years. In total, approximately $80 billion in debt has been deployed since 2015, highlighting growing lender confidence as technology models mature. Geographically, North America has remained resilient with over 40 per cent of postboom funding, while European companies experienced a nearly 50 per cent decline between 2024 and 2025, reflecting a regional shift in priorities towards security and resource resilience.
Top performers are cheaper, faster, and better
Analysis of the 250 top-performing operational cleantech companies reveals a clear pattern for success. These companies thrive by being cheaper than conventional alternatives, faster than peers to market, and better than others in combining product quality with superior business models. Collectively, these 250 companies have raised approximately $166 billion in equity—representing 45 per cent of all cleantech equity raised since 2015—and employ roughly 180,000 people.
Cheaper: winning on economics, not ideology
Equity investment is twice as concentrated in technology areas where cleantech solutions are already cheaper than the conventional alternatives they replace, such as electric vehicles and renewable energy. The top 10 lowest-cost subsegments captured 62 per cent of total investment ($102 billion), compared to only 27 per cent for the top 10 highest-cost subsegments. This underscores that in today’s selective market, capital is directed toward companies that demonstrate a clear value proposition beyond climate impact.
Top-tier players achieve this by targeting large value pools with structural cost advantages, designing for lower costs from day one through minimum viable products, and expanding across the capital stack as risks decline. For example, the battery manufacturer CATL achieves lower costs through vertical integration and scale, while the solar company Enpal uses a subscription model to eliminate up-front costs for households.
Faster: scaling fundraising and technologies at the right time
Top performers excel at maturing technology while progressing efficiently through funding stages. Approximately 60 per cent of top-tier companies advanced through more than two technology readiness level (TRL) stages between 2015 and 2025, and around 80 per cent achieved full maturity at TRL 9. These companies focus on rapid market entry using existing technology rather than prolonged innovation. For instance, Form Energy matured its iron-air batteries by aligning innovation with grid needs and scaling early with utility partners, while Fervo Energy adapted proven oil and gas techniques for geothermal systems to enable faster iteration.
Better: the ultimate competitive moat
Successful companies outperform peers on multiple dimensions beyond sustainability, such as performance, advanced features, and business model innovation. Roughly 80 per cent of top performers compete on advanced features, and they typically report competing across an average of 4.6 dimensions compared with 3.3 for the broader market. This multidimensional advantage rests on superior products and strong operating models that reduce execution risk. Examples include Octopus Energy, which uses its Kraken IT platform to manage a decentralised service model, and 3RT, which transforms low-value pulpwood into premium hardwoods with a lower sustainability footprint.
The pitfalls: what separates successes from those who almost made it
Analysis of more than 20 top equity raisers that ceased operations reveals avoidable missteps. The most common pitfall is ‘raising too fast, building too slow,’ where fundraising outpaces operational readiness. Northvolt raised approximately $1 billion across eight rounds but faced production challenges that led to bankruptcy in 2025. Other failures involved taking on significant technology risk without commercial validation, such as Lilium’s eVTOL aircraft, or neglecting competitive unit economics, as seen with Nikola’s heavy trucking trajectory. These cases highlight that technical ambition must be matched by a validated, financeable commercial model.