Environment and national security - exploring the risk pathways: Forward-looking research agenda
This report establishes a research agenda linking environmental degradation to UK national security. It examines six themes: critical natural infrastructure, resource management, shipping, migration, nature weaponisation, and societal resilience. It identifies evidence gaps and proposes nearly 200 research questions to inform future policy interventions.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
1. Introduction
The Agile Initiative research “sprint” involved researchers from the University of Oxford working with policymakers from 15 UK Government departments, statutory bodies, and military services. This forward-looking research agenda identifies six priority focus areas to address the climate and biosphere emergency and its implications for national security. The report defines national security as the UK’s ability to protect its population, economy, critical infrastructure, institutions, and strategic autonomy from military, geopolitical, economic, technological, environmental, or social shocks and threats.
2. Conceptual framework and causal pathways
The project developed a framework connecting a healthy environment—including biodiverse ecosystems and a stable climate—to the delivery of resources, infrastructure, and services. These in turn support socio-economic prosperity, geopolitical stability, and national security. The framework identifies that unsustainable resource use and infrastructure construction can damage biodiversity and climate stability, undermining essential goods and services and driving migration from stressed regions.
3. Policy baseline: Where are we? UK Government’s environment and national security position
UK Government activity in this area is increasing but remains fragmented and siloed. Three dominant narratives exist: a conflict narrative, a threat-multiplier narrative, and a risk and resilience narrative. Energy security is the most mature and extensively used concept. Climate security has wide resonance but fuzzy conceptual boundaries. Nature security is the least settled term, with causal chains seen as complex, longer-term, and mediated through other systems. The report notes signs that climate security and nature protection are being de-prioritised due to immediate concerns like the Russia-Ukraine conflict and the cost-of-living crisis.
4. Critical natural infrastructure
Urgent intervention is needed to protect critical natural systems, including tropical forests and ocean ecosystems that sustain global carbon and water cycles. Wild pollinators are declining globally, threatening the production of fruit, vegetable, and oilseed crops. In the UK, high-grade agricultural land is at risk from floods, droughts, and sea-level rise. Urban green spaces are vital for climate resilience but are under threat from development pressures. The report suggests identifying Global Systemically Important Natural Systems that are ‘too big to fail’.
5. Resource management: food and energy demand
Action has largely focused on supply, but managing demand is critical. The Climate Change Committee recommends a 20% reduction in red meat and dairy consumption by 2030 to reach net-zero goals. In 2021, UK food waste amounted to 10.7 million tonnes. The shift to renewables increases reliance on critical minerals; for example, a typical electric car requires six times the mineral input of a conventional car. Future research must address supply chain chokepoints and the circular economy to reduce reliance on imported minerals.
6. Shipping and UK trade
Shipping is vital for national security, as 98% of imported goods by value arrive by sea. Ports are vulnerable to climate hazards, such as drought affecting the Panama Canal. Arctic sea-ice decline may open new trade routes, but accidents in the region are severe due to remoteness. Maritime insurers estimate a major Arctic shipwreck could cost USD 1 billion. The energy transition will reshape routes and infrastructure, including the role of green ammonia as a low-carbon fuel.
7. Downstream migration response
Climate migration is primarily directed towards cities within the country of origin or neighbouring nations. While some climate-related migrants may arrive in the UK as part of diasporas, UK communities also face domestic displacement. Up to a third of all UK homes could be at risk of flooding in the future, necessitating improved governance for ‘managed retreat’. More-than-human mobilities, including the movement of pests and diseases like West Nile virus and the tiger mosquito, pose new biosecurity threats.
8. Weaponisation of nature and weather
Nature is being weaponised more frequently by state and non-state actors. Adversaries may use sabotage to poison water, start wildfires, or disrupt cooling and heating systems. Emerging dual-use technologies, such as geoengineering, cloud seeding, and solar radiation management, enable new forms of hybrid warfare. The report suggests reviving the Environmental Modification Convention and pursuing the recognition of ecocide as an international crime.
10. Societal resilience and mental capital
Environmental stress erodes the mental, social, and economic capital that allows communities to absorb and recover from shocks. Access to ‘forgotten ecosystems’—small, informal green spaces—supports mental capital and resilience. The report identifies a need to embed mental capital equity tests into infrastructure and adaptation decisions and to protect overlooked habitats.
11. Communicating the environment – national security nexus
Communication is challenging due to the psychological distance of environmental risks. Public concern is highest for immediate, visible issues like food costs and energy prices. Effective framing should use tangible “hooks”, such as the fact that the UK only has 72 hours of food stocks, to motivate action. It is essential to tackle misinformation and demonstrate that integrated policy helps address immediate economic problems.
12. Behavioural and institutional levers for change
The project identified 54 potential interventions. Most interventions provide multiple benefits across different dimensions of security. A circular economy shift can reduce waste and the need for raw material extraction from sensitive ecosystems. Current governance barriers include spread-out responsibilities and a system better suited for response rather than prevention. Behavioural science is crucial for ensuring interventions are accepted and sustained.
13. Conclusions and next steps
An integrated and coordinated approach across government is urgently required. Future steps should involve wider discussions with academics, practitioners, businesses, and the third sector to embed environmental security into policy. A concerted effort is needed to monitor effective interventions and ensure a safe and secure future.