EUDR Compliant Plus: The value of soy sustainability standards in the EU context
This report assesses 20 soy voluntary standard systems against EU Deforestation Regulation requirements. It finds independent, multi-stakeholder standards consistently outperform corporate-led schemes in legality, traceability, and human rights. Recommendations highlight the need for segregated supply chains and robust third-party verification to support corporate due diligence and environmental compliance.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Summary
This report, commissioned by WWF Germany and updated in October 2026, evaluates the evolution of 20 soy Voluntary Standard Systems (VSS) in response to the European Union Deforestation Regulation (EUDR). The regulatory context has shifted significantly following the EU’s decision to postpone the application of the EUDR until 30 December 2025 for large and medium operators, and 30 June 2026 for small and medium enterprises (SMEs). Despite these delays, the core obligations concerning legality, geolocation, and a strict no-deforestation cut-off date of 31 December 2020 remain intact. The report clarifies that while certification is not a “green lane” for compliance, it is a valuable tool within corporate due diligence, particularly when third-party verified information is coupled with verified plot data to offer “EUDR Compliant Plus” physical streams.
Research approach and methodology
The 2025 benchmark update involved a desk review of the most recent public standard documents followed by a structured feedback round with each VSS provider. The assessment methodology uses a scoring system across five key themes, each weighted equally at 20 per cent: EUDR alignment (covering legality, no-deforestation, and traceability), conversion of non-forest ecosystems, good agricultural practices (GAP), social and human rights issues, and governance, transparency, and assurance. A robust scheme must perform consistently across all criteria to be considered a credible tool for ensuring deforestation-free and ethically produced soy in the European market.
VSS performance: overall results
The findings indicate that independent, multi-stakeholder standards consistently outperform corporate-led schemes in areas such as governance, transparency, and third-party assurance. Since the previous 2023 benchmark, many standards have tightened rules on legality and conversion, often introducing specific EUDR modules or tools. However, a significant challenge remains: many chains of custody still rely on mass balance models, which are inherently incompatible with the EUDR’s requirement for traceable, segregated flows. Furthermore, many VSS still need to ensure that geolocation data is properly linked to production dates and quantities, and that all relevant records are retained for at least five years to meet regulatory expectations.
VSS performance: individual results
Individual assessments reveal varying levels of readiness. Standards such as Donau Soja, Europe Soya, ISCC EU, ISCC Plus, ProTerra, and RTRS are identified as being well-aligned with key EUDR requirements and may serve as supportive measures for compliance. In contrast, several corporate standards, including those from ADM, Bunge, and Cargill, currently lack certain essential elements. For example, ADM’s standard does not require geolocation collection for every batch of soy, and Bunge’s PRO-S relies on a mass balance approach that does not currently offer a defined, auditable segregated option. The report also notes that while most standards prohibit forced and child labour, provisions for living wages remain rare, with ISCC EU and ISCC Plus being notable exceptions.
Conclusions and recommendations
The report concludes that although the soy sector has made progress, the transition to segregated supply chains is a critical priority for VSS aiming to support EUDR requirements. Key recommendations for VSS providers include aligning forest definitions with AFi and EUDR standards, collecting geolocation data at the polygon level, and strengthening assurance systems by clearly defining non-conformity categories and reinstatement procedures. Downstream buyers and financial institutions are advised to recognise credible third-party verified VSS as essential risk assessment tools and to incorporate the share of certified soy as a key performance indicator in sustainability-linked loans.
To EU regulators, the report recommends ensuring consistency and predictability in EUDR guidelines and extending legal protections to other natural ecosystems, such as savannahs, peatlands, and wetlands. It also calls for the enforcement of due diligence obligations for EU financial institutions that finance commodities within the scope of the regulation. Finally, the report emphasises that the robustness of any standard ultimately depends on field-level controls and the independence of third-party audits.