Nuclear weapons no thanks - except in portfolios: Do asset managers break their own rules on investing in nuclear weapons producers?
This report investigates whether 15 major asset managers adhere to their nuclear weapons investment policies. It identifies significant loopholes, such as revenue thresholds, that permit continued funding of nuclear programmes. The findings reveal that many institutions prioritise government defence policies over international disarmament obligations, particularly in Europe and the USA.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Context: financial sector, nuclear weapons, international treaties
Nuclear weapons represent one of the most significant threats to global security, with the current danger of nuclear conflict reaching levels not seen in decades. The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT), established in 1968, remains the cornerstone of international efforts to prevent the spread of nuclear arms. While it prohibits non-nuclear states from acquiring weapons, it obliges the five recognised nuclear powers to pursue disarmament in good faith. More recently, the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) entered into force in 2021, providing a comprehensive ban on all nuclear activities, including financing. However, many financial institutions continue to ignore the TPNW, preferring to align their policies with the NPT, which lacks an explicit prohibition on financial support for weapon producers.
A new nuclear arms spiral?
Currently, nine states possess nuclear weapons. Five are parties to the NPT (Russia, USA, UK, China, and France), while four operate outside it (Pakistan, India, North Korea, and Israel). The global security environment is deteriorating as key control agreements, such as the New START treaty and the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty (CTBT), are eroded. All nuclear-armed states are currently modernising their arsenals or developing new types of weaponry, with expenditure in the sector exceeding $100 billion in 2024 alone. This modernisation arguably contradicts the disarmament obligations set out in the NPT.
The structure of the global nuclear weapons industry
While states are the primary buyers and controllers of nuclear weapons, the industry relies heavily on private corporations. Major companies involved in the production and maintenance of nuclear warheads and delivery systems include BAE Systems, Boeing, BWX Technologies, General Dynamics, Honeywell Aerospace, Lockheed Martin, and Northrop Grumman. These entities provide a range of services, including the construction of infrastructure, the development of nuclear-capable missiles, and the maintenance of existing arsenals.
The potential influence of the financial sector
Financial institutions exert influence as significant financiers and shareholders. Divestment campaigns and exclusion policies can increase the cost of capital for arms manufacturers, potentially forcing changes in business practices. However, since the invasion of Ukraine, many European financial institutions have loosened or scrapped their exclusion criteria to capitalise on rising government defence budgets and expected profits in the arms industry.
Controversial weapons as “sustainable investments”?
There is an ongoing redefinition of “controversial weapons” within the financial sector. EU regulations, such as the Defence Industrial Strategy 2024 and ESMA guidelines, increasingly classify the defence sector as “sustainable.” This allows sustainability-labelled (ESG) funds to invest in weapons manufacturers, provided they do not produce specifically prohibited items like cluster munitions. Nuclear weapons are frequently omitted from these prohibitions, enabling their inclusion in many ESG portfolios despite their indiscriminate nature and associated human rights risks.
Methodology and analysis of the policies of the 15 asset managers
The report analysed 15 of the world’s largest asset managers across the USA, Europe, and Germany. The findings reveal that none of these institutions excludes nuclear weapons across the board. Instead, exclusions are often limited to specific regions (such as BlackRock’s EMEA funds) or certain sustainability-labelled products. Many managers use revenue thresholds, typically 5%, which allows them to invest in major producers whose nuclear-related revenue falls below that mark. For example, corporations like Boeing and RTX generate billions from nuclear weapons but may still fall below a 5% threshold relative to their total revenue.
Investigation of possible breaches of nuclear weapons policies
The study identified several instances where actual investments appeared to contradict internal policies. In a case study of Israel, the report highlights its undeclared nuclear programme and the role of suppliers like Rafael and Elbit Systems. Several asset managers, including JPMorgan and Allianz, hold shares in Bharat Electronics and Hindustan Aeronautics, which support India’s nuclear missile programmes, despite policies that ostensibly exclude such support. Additionally, Union Investment funds were found to hold shares in Larsen & Toubro, a key contributor to India’s nuclear submarine programme. The report suggests that many asset managers employ narrow definitions of “nuclear weapon components” to avoid excluding major suppliers.
Conclusion
The study concludes that most Western asset managers prioritise the policies of their respective governments over the strict interpretation of international treaties. By focusing on non-proliferation while ignoring disarmament obligations, they continue to invest in companies that modernise nuclear arsenals. To achieve credible implementation of their own commitments, asset managers would need to exclude companies supporting nuclear programmes in non-NPT states and establish clear benchmarks for disarmament in NPT-recognised states.