Shifting supply chain interdependencies among global automakers
This research examines shifting supply chain interdependencies among global automakers from 2018 to 2024. It reveals a transition from a bipolar to a tripolar industrial structure, the fragmentation of traditional Western blocs, and the emergence of a China-centric electric vehicle ecosystem involving critical technological dependencies on Chinese batteries.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
The global automotive industry is currently navigating a once-in-a-century paradigm shift at the intersection of technological disruption through connected, autonomous, shared, and electric (CASE) vehicles and significant geopolitical realignment. The transition to electric vehicles (EVs) is fundamentally reconfiguring the intricate web of production and supply that underpins the entire sector. Recent global disruptions, including the COVID-19 pandemic and semiconductor shortages, have exposed inherent vulnerabilities, transforming supply chain resilience from an operational concern into a paramount national strategic imperative. This research tracks the dynamic evolution of structural changes across component categories over time, specifically examining the horizontal network of interdependencies among original equipment manufacturers (OEMs).
Data and descriptive analysis
The empirical foundation of this study is a comprehensive dataset of automotive supply chain relationships sourced from the MarkLines information platform. The analysis focuses on the relationships of the top 25 global OEM groups and their Tier-1 suppliers between 2018 and 2024, involving 277,157 unique supply linkages. Descriptive analysis reveals a profound technological substitution at the component level. The number of recorded supply relationships for internal combustion engine (ICE) powertrain components plummeted by nearly 50% from 2018 to 2024, with its share of total transactions falling from approximately 35% to under 20%. In contrast, relationships for e-powertrain components surged, reflecting a rapid reallocation of sourcing activity towards electrification.
The market is characterised by high fluidity and supplier churn. In 2021, over half of the active suppliers were new compared to the previous year, with this influx being most pronounced in the e-powertrain category. Simultaneously, a high annual exit rate was recorded, with more than 30% of suppliers exiting the dataset each year, particularly in the ICE-powertrain category. This churn has led to a significant reordering of hub suppliers. While established Western and Japanese firms dominated in 2018, by 2024, the landscape had shifted, with Japan’s Denso rising to the top and a notable increase in suppliers specialising in entire vehicle architectures and electronics.
Diverse strategic positioning is evident among OEMs regarding their procurement strategies. Traditional OEMs such as Toyota, Nissan, and Honda typically pursue horizontal collaboration, engaging with many suppliers shared with other manufacturers. Conversely, firms like Tesla and BYD pursue vertical integration strategies, emphasising in-house production or exclusive supplier relationships. By 2024, BYD emerged in a highly distinctive position with a large number of transactions but a sharing ratio below 50%. This trend is particularly pronounced in the e-powertrain category, where BYD’s sharing ratio dropped to approximately 35%.
Analytical framework
The study investigates the relational structure among global automakers by representing raw data as a bipartite network, which is then projected into a unipartite, weighted OEM-OEM network based on shared suppliers. An edge exists between two OEMs if they share at least one common Tier-1 supplier, with the edge weight serving as a measure of interdependency. The research employs the Louvain method, a heuristic algorithm based on modularity maximisation, to identify industrial blocs or communities. This allows for the tracing of the formation and dissolution of industrial ecosystems across different model years and part categories.
Results: evolving structure of global automotive supply chains
The analysis of the aggregate network reveals a dramatic transformation between 2018 and 2024. In 2018, the network exhibited a broadly bipolar structure consisting of a highly integrated bloc of 26 OEMs including major Japanese, American, and European firms, and a distinctly Chinese-centric community of 20 firms. By 2024, this fractured into a tripolar world. The formerly monolithic incumbent bloc split into a European-Korean community (including BMW, Renault, and Hyundai/Kia) and a Japanese-American community (including Nissan, Toyota, GM, and Ford). Meanwhile, the Chinese-centric community grew significantly in size and internal cohesion, indicating a move towards a more self-sufficient supply ecosystem.
Divergent evolutionary paths are observed between legacy and emerging technologies. The ICE-powertrain network has reorganised into geographically defined communities, suggesting a consolidation of legacy supply chains. In sharp contrast, the e-powertrain network evolved from a fragmented state in 2018 to a dense, globally interconnected system by 2024. This new ecosystem features a massive Chinese-centric community and a separate European-Korean community. Notably, a new Japanese-led community emerged that includes the Chinese giant BYD. This is driven by specific ties between BYD and Japanese joint ventures in China, such as FAW Toyota sourcing core powertrain components from BYD’s subsidiary, FinDreams, to meet local market demands.
Conclusion
The study confirms a significant structural realignment of the global automotive industry, with the traditionally integrated Japan-US-Europe bloc fragmenting as a self-sufficient Chinese-centric ecosystem emerges. These findings have critical implications for corporate managers, who must adopt technology-specific supply chain strategies focusing on regional efficiency for ICE components and managing complex global dependencies for electric vehicles. For policymakers, the clear emergence of a dominant Chinese-centric e-powertrain network highlights a formidable strategic challenge and reinforces the rationale for industrial policies aimed at building resilient and diversified domestic supply chains for essential components like batteries and semiconductors.