Advancing social equity through impact management
This report provides a framework for investors to advance social equity through impact management. It details four steps: setting strategy, integrating goals, optimising performance via participatory data collection, and reinforcing accountability through inclusive governance. The guidance uses multidisciplinary best practices to improve outcomes for historically marginalised communities.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction to the four steps of impact management
This document provides guidance for investors seeking to promote social equity, defined as the condition that would be achieved if social identity, such as race, gender, or sexuality, no longer influences how one fares in society. Social equity is framed as both a process and an outcome; process-oriented changes in decision-making serve as leading indicators for more equitable outcomes in communities that are currently or have been historically marginalised. The report introduces a multidisciplinary framework comprising four steps: set strategy, integrate, optimise, and reinforce. These steps were developed through a year-long effort involving literature reviews and collaboration with expert partners to fill the knowledge gap between the adoption of social equity strategies and the ability to manage and report on their impact effectively.
Step 1: set strategy
Investors begin by defining equitable goals that centre the priorities of marginalised communities. Strategies typically focus on three outcome areas: equitable access to capital, greater workplace equity, and equitable access to products and services. The report identifies two entry points for setting these goals: focusing on specific sectors or themes, or focusing on specific social identities through intersectional analysis. To ensure lasting improvements, investors are encouraged to articulate an impact thesis that addresses structural drivers of inequity rather than just institutional failings. Tools such as root-cause analysis and systems mapping help identify why certain conditions exist. For example, Case Study 1 details how the Melville Charitable Trust focused on root causes of homelessness for Black, Indigenous, and Latine populations, identifying racist housing and zoning policies as a primary driver. Mitigation measures for impact risks in this stage include avoiding the ‘tokenising’ of participants and anticipating potential resistance or retrenchment from political or social opponents.
Step 2: integrate
In this phase, investors embed impact goals throughout the investment process by choosing systematic approaches to assess impact potential. Common methods include impact ratings and scorecards, monetisation, and standardised indicators like the IRIS+ racial equity theme. The Raza Development Fund, for instance, utilizes a scorecard with 45 indicators to increase opportunities for Latino families. The report highlights the critical importance of qualitative data in understanding power imbalances and diverse experiences. It recommends using tools like the Racial Equity Assessment that is Proactive and Practical (REAPP) survey to balance information needs with the burden placed on borrowers. To mitigate biases, investors can partner with ecosystem experts, remove identifying information from credit applications, and incorporate lived experience directly into the diligence process. For example, Village Capital shifted authority by using a peer due diligence process where founders assess each other, resulting in nearly 50% of selected startups being women-led, compared to the industry average of approximately 15%.
Step 3: optimise
Investors monitor progress and take actions to maximise impact achievement using participatory approaches. This means involving affected communities in deciding what data is collected, how it is used, and how identities are captured. Such methods ensure that marginalised groups gain substantial control over processes. The report suggests using evaluative techniques such as outcome harvesting, collaborative performance indicators, and empowerment evaluation to build community agency. For instance, the Buen Vivir Fund monitors impact using self-determined key performance indicators identified by grassroots partners. Technical assistance is also identified as a tool for equity; the Shell Foundation provides gender-smart support that helped investees double production and increase sales by over 50%. Data disaggregation is encouraged to uncover persistent inequities, as seen in the work of ALIVE Ventures, which reports disaggregated outcome data by gender across five investment themes in Latin America.
Step 4: reinforce
The final step involves deepening accountability through inclusive governance and equitable information distribution. Investors can prioritise diversity within their own Boards and Investment Committees to align decisions with equity goals. The Chicago Teacher’s Pension Fund increased its assets in Minority, Women, and Disability-Owned Business Enterprise firms from 6% to 48% by diversifying its leadership. Participatory governance models, such as the Olamina Fund’s Community Advisory Board, provide community members with veto power on investment decisions. When reporting, investors should use ‘asset-framing’ to focus on community strengths and aspirations rather than deficits. Case Study 2 examines the Growth Impact Fund, which invests in diverse-led social purpose organisations in the UK. One investee, Inclusion Labs, received a £200,000 equity investment to help schools conduct equity audits. To manage governance risks, the report suggests using implicit bias assessments and establishing grievance mechanisms to allow communities to raise concerns about unintended negative impacts.