How does capital flow to poor countries? Evidence from venture capital and private equity
This report investigates capital flows to poor countries via an experimental survey of 1,485 investors. It reveals a ‘poor-country penalty’ linked to institutional quality. While emerging market specialists apply smaller penalties through active risk management, developed market investors frequently avoid these destinations entirely, significantly impacting global capital allocation.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Why so little capital flows to poor countries has long been a central question in economics and finance. This paper addresses this issue specifically within the context of venture capital (VC) and private equity (PE), which play vital roles in financing firm growth and productivity. The research addresses the challenge of determining how identical firms would be evaluated in different countries by using a randomised experiment combined with a structured survey of investment practices. Conducted in partnership with the International Finance Corporation (IFC), the study surveyed 1,485 VC and PE investors across 108 countries, collectively managing approximately $2 trillion in assets under management (AUM). This large-scale study aims to open the ‘black box’ of how professional investors evaluate opportunities and manage risks globally.
Institutional setting and data
The research focuses on VC and growth equity, which are key segments of private capital in emerging markets (EMs). The authors designed separate survey instruments for VC and PE investors to reflect differences in investment stages and capital structures. The survey targeted senior decision-makers, including managing partners and associates, with a median response time of 36 minutes. To ensure data reliability, 1,001 respondents were matched to PitchBook records to validate reported AUM and historical investment counts. Investors were categorised into EM investors (those focusing primarily on emerging markets) and developed market (DM) investors (those focused on developed markets or global investing without a specific EM focus).
How do global investors make decisions? Experimental evidence
The core of the study is an incentivised experiment where respondents rated their interest in ten randomly generated, synthetic company profiles on a seven-point scale. The attributes—including financial performance, governance, management team characteristics, and geographic location—were randomised independently. The findings show that operating performance is the strongest determinant of investment interest. For example, reporting an EBITDA margin of 10% or more raises interest by approximately 0.55 points, while high sales growth increases it by 0.27 points. Governance rights, such as board representation, also significantly increase interest.
Crucially, the experiment reveals a substantial ‘poor-country penalty’. Otherwise comparable firms receive significantly lower evaluations when located in poorer countries. Firms in China or the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) face a penalty of approximately 0.7 points relative to the United States. Penalties of 0.4 to 0.5 points apply to Sub-Saharan Africa, Southeast Asia, Eastern Europe, and Latin America. This penalty is large enough to offset major improvements in firm fundamentals; for example, a high-profitability firm in MENA attracts similar interest to a low-profitability firm in the US. This penalty is most strongly associated with institutional quality, specifically regulatory quality and the rule of law, rather than simple geographic distance or cultural ties.
The magnitude of this penalty varies starkly by investor specialisation. DM investors apply much larger penalties (ranging from 0.7 to 0.95 points) than EM investors, whose penalties are generally between 0.5 and zero. For instance, holding firm attributes fixed, DM investors assign a 0.7-point penalty to firms in Kenya, whereas the penalty among EM investors is only 0.05 points and is not statistically significant. This suggests that EM investors have a fundamentally different approach to evaluating risks in these environments.
Venture capital and private equity practices around the world
The structured survey reveals that basic investment practices, such as seeking board representation and using equity-centred financing, have converged globally. Preferred equity is the leading instrument for VCs, while PE respondents primarily rely on straight equity. However, significant differences emerge in information sourcing and risk management. EM investors are 17.5 percentage points more likely to value local knowledge in management teams. They rely more heavily on in-house research and fund networks to assess countries, whereas DM investors more frequently respond to perceived risk by avoiding regions entirely.
Exit strategies also differ significantly. EM investors report substantially greater difficulties exiting investments, being 25.7 percentage points more likely to cite weak IPO markets and 20.3 percentage points more likely to cite weak M&A markets as major constraints. Consequently, EM investors focus more on international sales and sales to financial buyers. In terms of risk management, EM investors are more active, frequently using scenario analysis, cultivating government relationships, and employing contractual tools to mitigate currency and political risks.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that simply promoting promising firms or increasing capital supply may not be sufficient to attract investment to poor countries. The ‘poor-country penalty’ remains a massive barrier, driven by weak institutions and exit opportunities. A key role is played by which intermediaries consider these firms and how they evaluate risk. Mobilising private capital may require not just more money, but the building and sharing of specialised expertise and practices suited for investing in challenging country environments. Policymakers should consider both the institutional environment and the specific needs of the intermediaries operating within it to expand financing beyond those already specialised in emerging markets.