Catalyst capital: Investing with heart and head
This report explores ‘Catalyst Capital’, an impact-investing approach combining financial returns with community benefits. It details legal structures for purpose-led organisations, including limited partnerships and debt models. Case studies from New Zealand and Canada illustrate successful applications in social housing, health equity, and renewable energy to drive social change.
Please login or join for free to read more.
OVERVIEW
Introduction
Steven Moe, a Partner at Parry Field Lawyers, introduces the concept of “Community Capital” as a way of thinking about capital that recognises funds, community, environment, and social impacts. A catalyst is defined as something that causes chemicals to react that otherwise would not; similarly, catalysing community capital is an additional tool to promote investment into meaningful local projects providing both financial returns and community impact. The report is intended for those interested in impact-focused investment and those seeking such investment for their companies.
Part 1: for those who are curious about what this way of investing is
The report contrasts the traditional approach to investment with impact investing. Traditionally, organisations like charities might invest a spare $10 million in long-term bank deposits to earn interest, which is then used for grants. In this model, only the use of profits is considered, rather than where the capital itself is placed. The alternative approach involves investing a portion of that capital directly into mission-aligned businesses, such as social housing providers. This advances the organisation’s cause while still providing a financial return. Impact must be measured across categories like education, climate, or housing. Investors are also encouraged to consider “additionality,” questioning if their investment adds value beyond what a bank could provide.
Part 2: for those who want to become heart and head investors
“Heart and Head Investing” is defined as an investment, not a donation, that creates both impact and financial return. Ethically motivated companies solving “wicked problems” may perform better than traditional investments. The report highlights the rise of consumer support for ethical supply chains and mentions that individuals can easily engage in this approach through KiwiSaver providers. Risk management remains critical, requiring proper due diligence, specialist advice, and starting with small allocations.
Part 3: for those who are on boards of trusts investigating how they should invest their capital
Trustees of large foundations have a duty to consider impact investing. Many boards currently focus only on income from traditional investments, but the report argues they should rethink how capital itself is allocated to advance their purposes. A mindset shift is needed to overcome conservative views of “fiduciary duty” that limit risk appetite. Practical steps for boards include identifying mission-aligned startups or programmes and consulting investment advisors about aligned opportunities.
Part 4: those who want to receive investment into your venture or charity
Impact entrepreneurs can set up legal entities to attract investment through equity or debt models. In an equity approach, such as a limited partnership for a Youth Hub costing $10 million, wholesale investors can become owners and receive repayments from income generated by facilities, commercial rentals, and cafes. Alternatively, a debt approach involves loans at preferential interest rates. Unlike donations, these are documented with binding agreements and must be repaid. The report emphasises that ventures must tell a compelling story of impact beyond traditional metrics to attract investors.
Part 5: key legal considerations (the best structure options)
Key legal structures for catalytic investing include Limited Partnerships, where limited partners invest money and a general partner runs the project. This structure is tax-effective as partners are taxed at their individual rates. Companies are also well-understood options, allowing for the issuance of shares and dividends. Charities may also participate by partnering with other organisations to co-invest.
Conclusion
Catalysing capital presents an opportunity to combine financial returns with direct community impact. Implementation may require organisations to amend founding documents or adopt new investment policies. By learning from global practices, organisations can become catalysts for impact in their local communities.
Annex 1: a few case studies
The report provides several case studies:
- Hamilton Community foundation (canada): Committed $62.9 million to total impact investment, including a $6.25 million investment into the Canadian Canoe Museum and support for the Raven indigenous impact fund, which targets returns of six to eight percent.
- Community housing funding agency (NZ): Raised over $500 million from philanthropic and mainstream investors to provide lower-rate finance to community housing providers.
- Kitea health (soul Capital): An Auckland medical device company focusing on health equity for Māori and Pasifika hydrocephalus patients.
- OpenStar technologies (soul Capital): A Wellington-based fusion energy company focusing on environmental impact and technical training for underrepresented groups.
- Supa energy (soul Capital): A solar hub initiative that shares financial benefits with host schools and marae.
Annex 2: the role of education
To stimulate impact-focused entrepreneurship, the report suggests providing education through webinars, startup accelerators, and grants. These initiatives help purpose-driven entrepreneurs find investment opportunities and can include options for the education provider to become an investor in emerging startups.